Quebec's police forces still overwhelmingly white - Action News
Home WebMail Thursday, November 14, 2024, 03:00 AM | Calgary | 6.0°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
MontrealINTERACTIVE

Quebec's police forces still overwhelmingly white

Quebec's population may be increasingly racially diverse but that's not reflected in police hiring. The SQ stands out: Just five of 735 officers hired in nine years are from "cultural communities."

Only 5 police officers from 'cultural communities' among 735 hired by Sret du Qubec in past 9 years

A Quebec human rights commission report released in 2015 found that the Sret du Qubec fails to properly represent visible minorities and people from ethnic communities in its police force. (Sret du Qubec)

Quebec's population may be increasingly racially diverse but that's not reflected in the provincial police force nor in municipal police forces surrounding Montreal.

Numbers compiled by CBC show that police forces in the greater Montreal region are lagging dramatically in their hiring of visible minorities.

The Sret du Qubec stands out: The provincial police force serves more than 2.5 million people, however, fewer than one per cent of its officers are not Caucasian.

Between 2007 and March 2015, the SQ hired 735new police officers.

Remarkably, only five of those hires were from what it calls "cultural communities" groups that have different national or cultural traditions from the main population.

Risk to police credibility

An expert on employment equity, Concordia University political scientist Maria Peluso, said thelack of diversity in Quebec's police forcesrisks underminingthe credibility of officers.

"In any public office or public institution, it's important theyreflect the diversity of the population that they serve," Pelusosaid.

"That adds a great deal of respect and credibility from the very population that you are there to serve and protect."

Mahad Al Mustaqim spent much of his youth in and out of jail as a member of a street gang. (CBC)
Mahad Al Mustaqimis a community activist who works with at-risk youth. He is a former street gang member.

"Today, we still have racial profiling," he said.

"I think if we had more visible minority officers, it would help [youth] to feel more safe, protected ... At the end of the day, more visible minority officers will help the community."

This pie chart represents all police officers hired by theSretduQubecbetween 2007 and March 2015:

Laval, Longueuil forces also behind

Statistics for regional police forces surroundingMontreal also show that recruitment from visible-minority communitieshas not been a priority.

In Laval, visible minorities make up 21 per cent of the total population but justthree per cent of the police force.

"Minority candidates are very welcome, but they have the same treatment as a non-minority candidate," said the Laval force's assistant director,France Liboiron.

Other municipalities, includingLongueuil and Chteauguay, have equally low numbers.

Peluso says it can be a vicious circle.

"With regards to visible minorities or any group that's been a victim of discrimination, they are not likely going to gravitate to those areas they feel are not welcoming," she said.

Province responds

Quebec's Public Security Minister MartinCoiteuxsays the province needs to do better.

"We have to work together to make sure that our public service in general and police service in particular are a [reflection] of the diversity of our society," he said, in response toCBC'sreport.

"In the past, we've made some efforts and we will continue making some efforts."

Coiteuxsaid the province is "progressing" but "perhaps not at the speed that we'd like."

SQ,SPVMslow to respond torequests

CBC compiled data on the hiring of visible minorities based on access-to-information requests to severalpolice forces, including theSretduQubecandthe Montreal police service (SPVM), as well as the police forces in Laval,Longueuil,Chteauguay,Saint-Eustache,Rousillon,Deux-Montagnes,Thrse-De-Blainville,TerrebonneandRepentigny.

TheSPVMdata is not yet included inCBC'sfindings, as its statistics are still in the mail.

The SQ has not provided any information, and CBC has compiled its statistics based on a recent report on the force bythe Quebec Human Rights Commission and theSQ'sannual reports.

TheTerrebonnepolice force has replied, saying it does not keep statistics on the racial background of its employees. CBC is appealing that response, asking for more information.


Real Talk on Raceis CBC Montreal's special series exploring personal conversations and experiences aroundrace in the city.


Compare thehiring practices of police forces when it comes to visible minorities:

On mobile? Go here to view the interactive graphic.

Research by: Anna Sosnowski

Graphics by: Molly Kohli

Interactive by: Sarah Leavitt