Her father defended the men who killed 2 Moncton police officers. It destroyed him and her family - Action News
Home WebMail Saturday, November 23, 2024, 03:46 AM | Calgary | -11.7°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
New Brunswick

Her father defended the men who killed 2 Moncton police officers. It destroyed him and her family

In the book Life Sentence: How My Father Defended Two Murderers and Lost Himself, Amy Bell discovered another side of her father. He hadkept the fact that he was a lawyer secret and refused to speak of the Moncton case even on his death bed.

Ed Bell represented at trial the 2 men who killed Const. Michael O'Leary and Cpl. AurleBourgeois in 1974

Black and white photo of man holding book. Printed under the photo are the words
Ed Bell was well-known in the Moncton community and involved with the Liberal Party of New Brunswick before he left the law profession and moved to a secluded area with his daughter and son. (Submitted by Nimbus Publishing)

In December 1974, two Moncton police officers disappeared while searching for the kidnappers of a 14-year-old boy.

On Dec. 15 that year, Const. Michael O'Leary and Cpl. AurleBourgeois were found shot to death andburied in shallow graves outside of Moncton.

Police picked up Richard Bergeron, who was known as Richard Ambrose at the time,andJames Hutchinson. Theywere charged with kidnapping, then later capital murder.

The case still haunts the community. So why, 48 years later, was the daughter of the lawyerwho defended Hutchinson and Ambrosetotally unaware of it? And howdid it destroy her family?

These arethe questions Amy Bell, history professor at Huron University College in London, Ont., and the daughter of then-defence lawyer Ed Bell, is trying to answer in her new book. The murders had a profound impact on the community and everyone involved, and her family was no exception.

A police officer is shown in a black and white photo. It's a headshot.
Cpl. Aurle Bourgeois, above, and Const. Michael O'Leary, who were investigating the kidnapping, reported they were following a Cadillac. It was the last time anyone heard from them. (CBC)
A black and white headshot of a young man with short hair.
The bodies of O'Leary, shown here, and Bourgeois were found in shallow graves just outside Moncton on Dec. 15, 1974. (CBC)

"My father was away in Moncton so much during the trial that it ended his marriage," she said.

His law practice suffered, and he eventually stopped practising.

"A lot of clients deserted him. They didn't want to be associated with someone who would defend cop killers.

"Basically, we were never a family again."

Old man sitting in a recliner, holding a phone up to his ear
Ed Bell in his home in Moncton in 2006. (Submitted by Nimbus Publishing)

One of the men found responsible, James Hutchison, died in prison. The other, Bergeron, was just denied parole lastweek. He's now in his mid-70s.

In writing Life Sentence: How My Father Defended Two Murderers and Lost Himself, Bell discovered a side of her father she hadn't known. He hadkept the fact he was a lawyer secret and refused to speak of the case even on his death bed.

"He told people that he was a retired first-aid instructor," she said.

"He felt that the case had ruined his life, and he wished he'd never taken it."

Prosperous and charmed life, at first

Bell was only a year old at the time of the murders, so to discover howthe trial changed her father, she spoke to uncles, her father's friends and some of his law colleagues.

She learned that he was the first of his family to go to university. He earned a law degree from the University of New Brunswick, to the pride of his parents and siblings. He was also heavily involved in the Liberal Party and was close friends with former premier Louis Robichaud, she said.

Black and white film photo of two men being walking next to police
James Hutchinson, left, and Richard Bergeron (then known as Richard Ambrose) are led in to the Moncton courthouse in 1974. (CBC News)

Bell said her father had a practice in St.Georgeand took onminor criminal cases. When he was called in about the Monctonmurders, the two police officerswere still missing.

"It was not the violent crime that it later turned out to be," she said.

"He had hoped that his clients were innocent."

The case started with a kidnapped teenage son of a wealthy restaurateur, Cy Stein. Undercover police officersmissed the chance to intercept the $15,000 ransom drop, and the son was returned safely.

I felt like I was travelling through the trial with him.- Amy Bell, author

A large part of the book recalls the trial. Amy Bell said she was struck by the standard of evidence used in the trialand somewhat understood the uphill battle her father faced.

"For the identification parades, it was almost deliberately flawed," she said. "Hutchinson waswithout a belt or shoelaces that made it very clear that he was the one that was in prison.

"My dad spoke out against these practices, but the judge was not interested."

Amy Bell read court transcripts but also hadlegal strategies that her father wanted to use. She said seeing her father's notes made her feel closer to him.

"I felt like I was travelling through the trial with him," she said.

Sentenced to death

The two men were first sentenced to death, but thatwas converted to life sentences when capital punishment was abolished.

Hutchinson died in prison in 2011 at the age of 83.

Amy Bell said researching and writing the book has helped her understand why her father was so invested in the case. He believed in the concept of innocent until proven guilty but was shunned for defending the two men.

"He was in some ways a hated figure in Moncton in the 1970s. And now he gets to tell his side through his own words, through the court transcript, and I've tried to put him as much as possible at the centre of the story."

'All of that promise and happiness was gone'

A photo of a woman with brown hair smiling.
Amy Bell is the author of Life Sentence: How My Father Defended Two Murderers and Lost Himself. (Submitted by Nimbus Publishing)

After the trial, her father and mother split up, and Ed Bell started drinking more heavily. Her mother dieda few years later.

"My father became a single parent, living in kind of poverty and isolation, so all of that promise and happiness and nuclear middle class family, all of that was gone."

She said in the book that while her father maintained everyone deserves a defence, he "bitterly regretted" taking on this case.

Her brother ended up in foster careand developedproblems with drugs. He died in a caraccidentat just 39 years old, Bell said.

"In a way, there's only me left to tell this story of my family. I'm the only one left."

She said writing the book not only helped her learn about her father and her family, but also about her own relationship with her father.

"We had a good relationship, but it was at times difficult," she said. "This was a difficult book to write, but it was also cathartic."

With files from Information Morning Fredericton

Add some good to your morning and evening.

Get the latest top stories from across New Brunswick in your inbox every weekday.

...

The next issue of CBC New Brunswick newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in theSubscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.