Capital gains tax change draws ire from some Canadian entrepreneurs worried it will worsen brain drain

A chorus of Canadian entrepreneurs and investors is blasting the federal government's budget for expanding a tax on the rich. They say it will lead to brain drainandfurther degradeCanada's already poor productivity.

In the 2024 budget unveiled Tuesday, Finance MinisterChrystia Freelandsaid the government would increase the inclusion rate of the capital gains tax from 50 per cent to 67 per cent for businesses and trusts, generating an estimated $19 billion in new revenue.

Capital gains are the profits that individuals or businesses make from sellingan asset like a stock or a second home. Individuals are subject to the new changes on any profits over $250,000.

The government estimates that the changes would impact 40,000 individuals (or 0.13 per cent of Canadians in any given year)and 307,000 companies in Canada.

However, some members of the business community say that expanding thetaxable amountwill devastate productivity, investment and entrepreneurship in Canada, and might even compel some of the country's talent and startups to take their business elsewhere.

WATCH | The federal budget hikes capital gains inclusion rate:

Federal budget adds billions in spending, hikes capital gains tax

1 month ago

Duration 6:14

Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland unveiled the government's 2024 federal budget, with spending targeted at young voters and a plan to raise capital gains taxes for some of the wealthiest Canadians.

Benjamin Bergen, president of the Council of Canadian Innovators(CCI), said the capital gains tax has overshadowed parts of the federal budget that the business community would otherwise be excited about.

"There were definitely some other stars in the budget that were interesting," he said. "However, the ... capital gains piece really is the sun, and it's daylight. So this is really the only thing that innovators can see."

The CCI has written and is circulating an open letter signed by more than 1,000 people in the Canadian business community to Trudeau's government asking it to scrap the tax change.

ShopifyCEO Tobi Ltke and president Harley Finkelstein also weighed in on the proposed hike on X, formerly known as Twitter.

Former finance minister Bill Morneausaid his successor's budget disincentivizes businesses from investing in the country's innovation sector: "It's probably very troubling for many investors."

Canada's productivity a measure that compares economic output to hours worked has been relatively poor for decades. It underperforms against the OECDaverage and against several other G7 countries, including the U.S., Germany, U.K. and Japan, on the measure.

Bank of Canada senior deputy governor Carolyn Rogers sounded the alarm on Canada's lagging productivity in a speech last month, saying the country's need to increase the rate had reached emergency levels, following one of the weakest years for the economyin recent memory.

The government said it was proposing the tax change to make life more affordable for younger generations and fund efforts to boost housing supply and that it would support productivity growth.

A challenge for investors, founders and workers

The change could have a chilling effect for several reasons, with companies already struggling to accessfunding in a high interest rate environment, said Bergen.

He questionedwhether investors will want tofund Canadian companiesif the government's taxation policies make it difficult for those firms to grow and whether founders might just pack up.

The expanded inclusion rate "is just one of the other potential concerns that firms are going to have as they're looking to grow their companies."

He said the rejigged tax is also an affront to high-skilled workers from low-innovation sectors who might have taken the risk of joining a startup for the opportunity, even taking a lower wage on the chance that a firm's stock options grow in value.

But Lindsay Tedds, an associate economics professor at the University of Calgary, said the tax change is one of the most misunderstood parts of the federal budget and that its impact on the country's talent has been overstated.

"This is not a major innovation-biting tax change treatment," Tedds said. "In fact, when you talk to realgrassroots entrepreneurs that are setting up businesses, tax rates do not come into their decision."

As for productivity, Tedds said Canadians might see improvements in the long run "to the degree that some of our productivity problems are driven by stresses like housing affordability, access to child care, things like that."

'One foot on the gas, one foot on the brake'

Somesay the government is sending mixed messages to entrepreneurs by touting tailored tax breaks like the Canada Entrepreneurs' Incentive, which reduces the capital gains inclusion rate to 33 per cent on a lifetime maximum of $2 million while introducing measures they say would dampen investment and innovation.

"They seem to have one foot on the gas, one foot on the brake on the very same file," said Dan Kelly, president of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business.

WATCH | Could the capital gains tax changes impact small businesses?:

How could capital gains tax increases impact Canadian small businesses? | Power & Politics

1 month ago

Duration 12:18

Some business groups are worried that new capital gains tax changes could hurt economic growth. But according to Small Business Minister Rechie Valdez, most Canadians won't be impacted by that change and it's a move to create fairness.

A founder may be able to sell their successful company with a lower capital gains treatment than otherwise possible, he said.

"At the same time, though, big chunks of it may be subject to a higher rate of capital gains inclusion."

Selling a company can fund an individual's retirement, he said, which is why it's one of the first things founders consider when they think about capital gains.

LISTEN | What does a hike on the capital gains tax mean?:

Mainstreet NS7:03Ottawa is proposing a hike to capital gains tax. What does that mean?

Tuesday's federal budget includes nearly $53 billion in new spending over the next five years with a clear focus on affordability and housing. To help pay for some of that new spending, Ottawa is proposing a hike to the capital gains tax. Moshe Lander, an economics lecturer at Concordia University, joins host Jeff Douglas to explain.

Dennis Darby, president and CEO of Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters, says he was disappointed by the change and that it sends the wrong message to Canadian industries like his own.

He wants to see the government commit to more tax credit proposalslike the Canada Carbon Rebate for Small Businesses, which he said would incentivize business owners to stay and help make Canada competitive with the U.S.

"We've had a lot of difficulties attracting investment over the years. I don't think this will make it any better."

Tech titan says change will onlyimpact richest of the rich

Toronto tech entrepreneur Ali Asaria will be one of those subject to the expanded capital gains inclusion rate but he says it's only fair.

"It's going to really affect the richest of the rich people," Asaria, CEO of open source platform Transformer Lab and founder of well.ca, told CBC News.

"The capital gains exemption is probably the largest tax break that I've ever received in my life," he said."So I know a lot about what that benefit can look like, but I've also always felt like it was probably one of the most unfair parts of the tax code today."

While Asaria said Canada needs to continue encouraging talent to take risks and build companies in the country, taxation policies aren't the most major problem.

"I think that the biggest central issue to the reason why people will leave Canada is bigger issues, like housing," he said.

"How do we make it easier to live in Canada so that we can all invest in ourselves and invest in our companies? That's a more important question than, 'How do we help the top 0.13 per centof Canadians make more money?'"