Home | WebMail | Register or Login

      Calgary | Regions | Local Traffic Report | Advertise on Action News | Contact

BusinessAnalysis

Greek crisis needs more than a Band-Aid solution: Don Pittis

For now, European politicians will have won the day if they can reach a deal to keep Greece from going terminal. But the country needs continued care to get back on the road to economic health.

Could Greece really be on the road to recovery?

European leaders, including IMF boss Christine Lagarde and the European Central Bank's Mario Draghi meet yesterday before resuming negotiations on the future of Greece. Success keeping Greece solvent and in in the eurozone will be seen as a political triumph, but Don Pittis says there is so much more yet to be done. (Associated Press)

It would be easy to make the case that Greece is the latest "sick man of Europe." So far, too much of the publicsquabblinghas been over who to blame for the illness.

There are early signs that Europe'spoliticians are finally moving past that and may actually come up with a plan this week to prevent a terminal financialcollapse in theMediterraneancountry.

For now at least, that shouldpreventthe Greek economic maladyfromturning into something worse.

If they succeed in hammering out a deal,European politicians will deserve congratulations. But the hardest partof revivingthe ailing Greek economy will still be in the future.

Blame game

It is a positive sign that the blamegame has been largely set aside. In earlier rounds, the Greeks were blamed for borrowing too much money and spending it foolishly. Europe was blamed for fudging the numbers to let Greece into the eurozone.

In a country traditionallyriven by class conflict, the poor blamed the rich for not paying taxes. The business class blamed bloated government, powerful unionsand luxury-class pensions.

At one point the Greeks pulled out their history books andblamed the German government for damage done by the Nazis, almost as if Greece'sown intervening spell of military dictatorship had never happened.

Finally the name calling seems to be quieting down as allsides start torealize how devastating a Greek collapse and exit could be for Greece, forEurope and, as Russia's VladimirPutinbegins to play his Greek cards, for theInternational Monetary Fund, one of the unexpected hardliners in the negotiations.

The easy-exit myth

Amotivatorfor all sides as the deadline approaches is the realization that the theory of a surgicaleuro exitand default is purelymythical.

Already the Canadian Greek community has beengrowing fearful about what willhappen if there is no deal, University of Toronto professorPhil Triadafilopoulossaid on CBC Radio yesterday.

Politically aware people of mygeneration will remember the film Z, whichtold the story ofan elected politician murdered by the Greek military dictatorship amid vicious street battles.For most younger Canadians the country'sviolent streak is forgotten. But not in theGreek community, many of whom came here toescape thatchaos.

"If we see a re-emergence of what's been a left-right split become radicalizedbecausethe economy's sent into a real panic,"Triadafilopoulostold Matt Galloway on CBC's Metro Morning,"this is worrying to people here."

Until now, Europe and Greecehave bothadopted the negotiating stance that it really did not matter whether they failed to reach a deal.Increasingly the two sides are recognizingtheir common interests.Greek banks verge on collapse, and would have collapsedalready without European support. The streets of Athens fill withdemonstrators from opposing sides.

The Europeans realize a default will cost France and Germany alone 150 billion. AvolatileGreece would representacontagiouswound on Europe'snether parts.

Higher taxes

The details of a deal are leaking out only slowly. An increase in some taxes. A higher retirement age.

This is on top of structural changes already completed as outlined by University College of Dublin economist Karl Whelan, who says Greece is gradually moving to get its house in order.

But even if a deal is done, European leaders cannot dusttheir handsand walk away. Greece remains a troubled country, weakened by austerity, drained ofcapital by the banking crisis, still burdened by an impossible debt. The rich and the educated have been running away.

The one bright spot of a default would have been that the country might have been given a fresh start. Pushing those loans into the future without getting the economy back on track is like lending to aperson unemployed by illness suchthattheycan't afford medical care. If they don't get well they can never pay you back.

It is easy to forget that for many Greeks the European experiment has been a success, one that was interrupted by the global cash crunch of 2008. AsTriadafilopoulosand others have noted, before this long-drawn-out debt crisis, Greece was on its way to becoming fully European as the children of workers and farmers became educated.

A financial deal with Europe and the IMF is essential to moving back into that sweet spot. But it is not sufficient.

"The sick man of Europe" has been used to describe so many different countries, most people don't realize to whichthe term first applied.

A deal this week may mean that for Greece, too, the illness is temporary, and the countrywill be able to take thefirst steps on the long road to recovery.