B.C. storm sparks questions about legality of trees on public property - Action News
Home WebMail Thursday, November 14, 2024, 03:51 AM | Calgary | 6.3°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
British Columbia

B.C. storm sparks questions about legality of trees on public property

A tree that fell onto a home during a wind storm and killed a woman sleeping inside has raised questions about who is responsible for maintaining trees on public property.

Vancouver Park Board official says city's tree inspection policy won't change anytime soon

Jill Calder was killed early Thursday morning when this tree fell through her home. (CBC)

A tree that fell on a homeduring a wind stormand killed a woman sleeping inside has raised questions about who is legally responsible for maintaining trees on public property.

Jill Calder died early Thursday morning when a tree broke through her roof while she was in bed. The one-metre-wide tree waslocated on a green belt behind her house in Port Moody, B.C.

Personal injury lawyer Shadrin Brooks says citiescan't be held legally liable for a treeon public landunless there's evidence theyhavebeen negligent in maintaining the tree. An argument could also be potentially made if a treewas obviously dead or dying.

"They're not necessarily responsible for every accident that occurs," he said."They have to have a reasonable policy and they have to follow their policybut they're not really responsible for every loss that occurs on their property."

HowardNormann,VancouverPark Board's director of park operations,says four officers inspect every tree in Vancouver at least once a year, and additional crews do maintenance year-round.

He says despite the tragedy in Port Moody on Thursday, and the increasing likelihood of inclement weather due to changing climates, Vancouver's tree maintenance program will remain status quo.

"I feel comfortable that the program we're currently using is working," he said. "We didn't have that many trees that came down last night or this morning."

However, Normann says residents should notify the city if theysee a tree that could be hazardous.