Oil price pain seeps into other sectors of Alberta economy

From airlines to beer-makers to wireless providers, withering crude prices have been a drag on businesses seemingly far removed from the oilpatch.

"Sometimes outside of Alberta, particularly there's some skepticism or even some derision against the petroleum sector," said Todd Hirsch, chief economist at ATB Financial.

"Some people actually feel it's getting its comeuppance... But they need to realize that it has broader implications for the whole economy."

Troubled skies

WestJet Airlines, based in Calgary, is shuffling around its schedules to reflect lower demand for flights to and from energy-focused destinations in Western Canada.

• WestJet suspends Fort McMurray to Kelowna service
• WestJet trims service between Calgary, Edmonton

On a recent quarterly conference call, there was also talk of potentially deferring the delivery of new planes and returning leased aircraft that are up for renewal next year.

"It's had a dramatic impact on WestJet," aviation consultant Rick Erickson said of the crude downturn. "Demand is down across the country but nowhere near as much as it is in Western Canada."

Traditionally, a big portion of airline traffic had been oil workers commuting to and from site from elsewhere in the country, said Erickson. With projects on hold, those volumes have tapered off.

Molson, Telus and Manulife

The crude downturn was even cited as cause for concern in the latest earnings for Molson Coors Brewing Co., which said on its quarterly call Thursday that beer drinkers particularly in Alberta are choosing economy brews over premium brands.

• Molson Coors says weak economy affecting beer sales in oil-producing provinces

The oilpatch pain was also evident in the latest financial report from Vancouver based Telus. The company added just 4,400 postpaid wireless customers in Alberta during the second half of last year, a sharp drop from the net 50,000 it added in the same period a year earlier.

Insurer Manulifetook a $250-million charge in the fourth quarter and a $876-million charge for 2015 as a result of a decline in its energy investments.

• Manulife profit falls 43% on losses in oil and gas

Retail pain

Data compiled by NPD Group, a research firm, paints a picture of how retail traffic has fared in different parts of the country in 2014 versus 2015.

Purchasing visits were down two per cent in Alberta and Atlantic Canada, while in the country as a whole, they were up three per cent.

The U.S. crude benchmark hit a high of around $108 USa barrel in mid-2014 and finished off 2015 below $40 a barrel. It's since depreciated further.

Thinking twice

Tough economic times cause consumers to scrutinize their discretionary purchases, said NPD Canadian retail analyst Sandy Silva.

All of a sudden those tried, tested and true guaranteed sales are not so guaranteed anymore- SandySilva,retail analyst,NPDGroup

"Can we have that extra meal out or can I have that new dress or new pair of shoes?" she said. "I think it's just going to cause consumers to think twice."

The retailers that are in for the most pain are ones that sell workwear, like steel-toed boots or flame-retardant coveralls, said Silva.

"All of a sudden those tried, tested and true guaranteed sales are not so guaranteed anymore."

Low oil prices do benefit the economy in some ways, said CIBC chief economist Avery Shenfeld. Lower fuel costs are welcome, for instance.

But the bad outweighs the good, he said.

"Make no mistake Canada is a major oil exporting economy and on balance it's a negative for the Canadian economy," said Shenfeld.

"That's made up for a deep negative from the oil-producing provinces and a modest positive for the rest of Canada."