Ottawa asked to intervene, reinstate Alberta's oilpatch monitoring

A dozen conservation and Indigenous groups have written federal Environment Minister Jonathan Wilkinson asking him to force the Alberta government to reinstate environmental monitoring in the province's oilpatch.

"We feel the federal government does have something at risk here," said Gillian Chow-Fraser of the Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society, one of the groups that signed the letter sent Tuesday.

The province's energy regulator decided earlier this spring that companies no longer have to live up to a wide array of environmental monitoring requirements that are a condition of their licences.

The suspensions include air, water, land and wildlife measures. Most have no end date.

The regulator says the decision was made to protect workers and communities during the COVID-19 pandemic.

• First Nations, environmentalists ask for restart of oilpatch monitoring

The signatories already sent a letter earlier this month to the Alberta government, askingthe provinceto restart oilpatch monitoring as soon as possiblegiven that other activities are coming out of the COVID-19 shutdown.

'Unilaterally suspended'

Chow-Fraser said the suspensions will affect Wood Buffalo National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage Site downstream from Alberta's oilsands. Federal assessments have already acknowledged the park is under threat and UNESCO has warned that the park's status could be endangered if environmental problems aren't addressed in a federal action plan.

"That action plan references all these provincial regulations and regulatory bodies that the plan said should protect the park," Chow-Fraser said.

"Those are the exact regulations that have been unilaterally suspended."

The signatories want Wilkinson to urge Alberta to end the suspensions and find out how they may have affected ongoing work at Wood Buffalo. They also want him to withhold any pandemic-related aid to the province's energy industry until the suspensions end.

The groups include the Fort Chipewyan Metis Association, the Northwest Territory Metis Nation and the Smith's Landing First Nation. Environmental groups include the Alberta Wilderness Association. The mayor of Fort Resolution, N.W.T., has also signed.

Other area First Nations are in favour of the letter.

"We do support it," said Melody Lepine of the Mikisew Cree.

Wilkinson's office wasn't immediately available for comment.

'We don't have any certainty'

In an email sent Tuesday, the Alberta Energy Regulator said the suspensions could come off as early as Aug. 15 if two ministerial orders from the province's energy and environment departments are left to expire.

It said that figures supplied by industry suggest that between 95 and 98 per cent of environmental regulations remain in place.

It also said Alberta's chief scientist, Fred Wrona, believes the suspensions won't harm the long-term quality of the province's monitoring data.

• Alberta Energy Regulator suspends environmental monitoring for oilpatch over COVID-19
• Alberta NDP leader calls for resumption of environmental monitoring at oil and gas sites

Chow-Fraser said waiting for the United Conservative government to decide when monitoring will resume isn't good enough.

"That's nice to hear, but we still don't have any certainty on that.

"They are very vague suspensions. There are no deadlines. We don't have any certainty that it won't be several months, half a year, a year."

Earlier this week, three different northern Alberta First Nations filed a request to appeal the regulator's decision to suspend monitoring. Their request points out First Nations weren't consulted, despite the decision's impacts on their treaty rights.

It also says the suspensions were made without any rationale linking specific activities to COVID-19 risks and despite work continuing at energy facilities. It adds the hold on monitoring came weeks after the province declared a state of emergency over the pandemic and just as Alberta was starting to ease its lockdown.