Ukrainians concerned as Red Cross considers opening office in Russia - Action News
Home WebMail Wednesday, November 13, 2024, 06:21 AM | Calgary | -0.3°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Manitoba

Ukrainians concerned as Red Cross considers opening office in Russia

The International Committee of the Red Cross confirmed it's considering opening up an office in Russia near the Ukrainian borderin a bid to scale up humanitarian efforts in the embattled area a move that stoked concerns among some Ukrainians.

Charity says it needs to explore all options to get aid into Ukraine

Mariupol resident Valentina Demura is pictured next to the wreckage of a building she once called home. The International Committee of the Red Cross is working to bring more humanitarian aid to the region, and said it is considering setting up a field office in Russia to do so. (Alexander Ermochenko/Reuters)

The International Committee of the Red Cross confirmed it's considering opening up an office in Russia near the Ukrainian borderin a bid to scale up humanitarian efforts in the embattled area a move that stoked concerns among some Ukrainians.

Dominik Stillhart, the director of operations for the International Committee of the Red Cross, said thecharity desperately needs to scale up itshumanitarian aid in EasternUkraine.

The organization is looking atwhetherit could getsupplies into Ukraine through Russia.

"There are discussions ongoing [of] where we can set up a logistical base. But for the time being, we don't have an office," he told CBC News.

With more than $82.5millionraised in Canada tosupport the charity's work in Ukraine, some have concerns about the optics and implications of the move.Ukraine's government on Sunday said itstrongly objects to the prospect of theRed Cross setting up an office in Russia.

Ukrainians living in Manitoba also voiced their objections to the move. "We were appalled, frankly," said Myroslava Pidhirnyj, a board member of theUkrainian Canadian Congress's Manitoba provincial congress.

WATCH | Red Cross considers opening office in Russia:

Outrage as Red Cross considers opening office in Russia for war relief efforts

3 years ago
Duration 2:04
The International Red Cross is looking at the possibility of opening an office in Russia a move that has already sparked outrage from members of the Ukrainian community. Red Cross officials argue the office would allow them to provide desperately needed aid to people in Eastern Ukraine.

"Would they be negotiating with Hitler? Would they be establishing a centrein Germany when people were actually being brought to their deaths?A similar thing is going on in Ukraine now."

'Overwhelming bulk' of aid money to be spent in Ukraine:Red Cross

No money has been spent in Russia yet, and the"overwhelming bulk" of money will continue to be spent insideUkraine, Stillhart said.

Right now, three-quarters of funds raised by Canadians are going directly into Ukraine, while the remainder is being spent in neighbouring countries helping refugees, like in Poland, Hungary, Romania and Moldova, he said.

Stillhart said it's important for the Red Cross to engage with Russia.

"We need to be perceived on the ground by the warring parties as neutral," he said.

"We need to have a minimum consensus that we can operate across these front lines. And that is what will help us and will continue to help us, hopefully, to reach even more people than today."

Myroslava Pidhirnyj, a board member of theUkrainian Canadian Congress's Manitoba provincial congress, says she and other members are 'appalled' that the Red Cross would consider setting up an office in Russia. (Trevor Brine/CBC)

Russia could exploit situation,expert says

Paul Larson,an expert in the supply chains for humanitarian aid and professor at theUniversity of Manitoba, applaudedthe Red Cross for trying to stick to its principles of neutrality and independence.

But he said doing so in this caseis a "very tricky matter," and said the optics of working in Russia could be perceived as theRed Crossendorsing the lies the Kremlin is espousing for its invasion.

"I can say personally, if it seemed like even an appearance of them endorsing that lie, they probably got my last donation for some time to come," he said.

Larson also warns there is a "big possibility" that supplies and resources sent into Russia for Ukraine could be stolen by the Russian military.

"There's numerous examples of aid going into war torn countries to help civilians, but that's essentially beenstolen by the military powers or the guys with the guns," he said.

"Given the recent history of what Russia is doing, I have no doubt that if they had a chance that they wouldexploit the situation."