After decades of searching, Indigenous families in Quebec push for answers about missing children - Action News
Home WebMail Sunday, November 10, 2024, 10:23 PM | Calgary | 0.3°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Montreal

After decades of searching, Indigenous families in Quebec push for answers about missing children

The province is expected to pass Bill 79 in the coming days. The legislation would allow Indigenous families to access information about children who went missing in the health-care system, but advocates say it isn't enough.

Quebec is passing legislation allowing families access to documents, but advocates say it isn't enough

Armand Echaquan, left, and eldest daughter, Viviane Echaquan Niquay, have been searching for answers into the disappearance of Viviane's little sister, Laureanna, for more than 40 years. (Julia Page/CBC)

WARNING: This story contains distressing details.

Laureanna Echaquan was just two months old when she was placed, completely alone, on a plane in Manawan, Que., bound for a Joliette hospital some 150 km away.

The infant had bronchitis and her parents, who had sought medical treatment for her, were not allowed to accompany her.

They never saw their child again.

Over four decades later, Laureanna's family have not given up their search for her.

They are part of a coalition of about 50 familieswhose children died or went missing while in the care of Quebechealth-care institutions.

The coalition, called Awacak an Atikamekw word that roughly translates to "little being of light" has been pushing for the adoption of Quebec's Bill 79.

Thelawwould allow Indigenous families to get information about children who went missing between the 1950s and 1990s after being taken to receive medical care. It is currently undergoing review and is expected to be passed in the coming days.

'It was not my daughter'

Viviane Echaquan Niquay can still vividly remember losing her baby sister, Laureanna, in 1973.

"She had told me, 'Baby Echaquan is being discharged," Echaquan Niquay recalls a social worker telling her over the phone.

But the next morning, the family received another call from the hospital, this time with grim news. They were told Laureanna had died.

When the family arrived at the funeral home in Joliette, they were taken to aStyrofoam coffin, which contained the body of a baby.

They were told that it was Laureannabut the family says the child weighed much more than their daughter, and appeared to be closer to 10 months old, not two months.

"It was not my daughter," said Armand Echaquan, the girl's father. "We knew they had switched her out for another baby."

(Echaquan is also the uncle of Joyce Echaquan, the Atikamekwwoman whose death in a Joliette hospital last September is currently being investigated by a Quebec coroner.)

Still, the couple wanted to give the child a proper burial. They asked that the body be buried in a cemetery in Joliette, but were told they could not bury her there, even though she had been baptized.

Instead, the child was buried in a corn field on the other side of the cemetery's fence. That space has since been turned into a soccer field.

For the past four years, Echaquan Niquay and her husband have been trying to find a death certificate, or any information about her sister's death.

Quebec Indigenous Affairs Minister Ian Lafrenire says the government is not expanding the bill to include a public inquiry into the disappearances. (Sylvain Roy Roussel/CBC)

"We were given three different dates of death for one person," said Echaquan Niquay.

The family is still holding out hope that Laureanna could be alive somewhere.

"Maybe she's still looking for us," Echaquan said. "What did they do with my child?"

Laureanna wasn't the first child the family lost. A few years earlier, Echaquan's wife had given birth to twins a girl and a boy.

The girl died just days after she was born, reportedly suffering from a heart condition. When the family asked to see the body, they were told it was too late.

To this day, the Echaquan family still doesn't know where she was buried, or even if she ever was.

Bill 79 not enough, advocate says

But while Bill 79 might help families get some answers, manyin the province feel it doesn't go far enough.

An Indigenous women's organizationhas been calling for an independent public inquiryinto all Indigenous children who wentmissing in the health-care system, youth protectionand residential schools.

Quebec Native Women president Viviane Michel says Bill 79 does not go nearly far enough. (Jean-Claude Taliana/CBC)

"Lovedones and families of the children have the right to find out the truth in the causes and systemic reasons for the disappearances of their children," said Viviane Michel, president of Quebec Native Women.

Michel says that many of the changes her group has proposed to the bill were not taken into account by Indigenous Affairs Minister Ian Lafrenire.

"The bill says nothing about the accompaniment of the families, does not specify what form the information will take," saidMichel.

She is also concerned that families whose children may have been forcefully and secretly put up for adoption outside the province or abroad will be given the runaround and she, like many, is calling for the bill to be expanded to include residential schools.

"We still ask ourselves, 'Are we currently walking on the bodies of our children?'" Michel said.

In a news conference Tuesday,Lafrenire said the government wasn't going to expand the bill to include a public inquiry into the disappearances, but he also said the government was open to holding an inquiry later if the demand was made by Indigenous communities.

Alain Arsenault, a lawyer who has been working with the Awacakcoalition, says the families are hoping some of those amendments, including the addition of residential schools to the bill, as well as access to information on exactly why their children went missing or died,will be added on eventually.

"[The families] still have some reservations, but for the momentthey prefer that they be able to start their work and then see what the limits are," said Arsenault.


Support is available for anyone affected by their experience at residential schools, and those who are triggered by the latest reports.

A national Indian Residential School Crisis Line has been set up to provide support for former students and those affected. People can access emotional and crisis referral services by calling the 24-hour national crisis line: 1-866-925-4419.

With files from Radio-Canada's Delphine Jung