Hampstead mayor won't apologize for describing Bill 21 as 'ethnic cleansing' - Action News
Home WebMail Wednesday, November 13, 2024, 05:58 AM | Calgary | 0.6°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Montreal

Hampstead mayor won't apologize for describing Bill 21 as 'ethnic cleansing'

Despite calls from other politicians to apologize for his comments, Hampstead MayorWilliam Steinberg opted instead to clarify them, somewhat.

Franois Legault says comments are 'unacceptable'

Mayor William Steinberg vetoed the July 15 vote against the project as councillor Harvey Shaffer was absent from that meeting. (Graham Hughes/Canadian Press)

Hampstead MayorWilliam Steinbergis facing growing pressure to apologize for saying Quebec's proposed religious symbol ban amounts to "ethnic cleansing."

But instead of apologizing, on Tuesday he opted to clarify his comments, referring to the ban's effect as a "peaceful ethnic cleansing."

Steinbergsaid.

"This is much more subtle. But over time, it will have the effect of making Quebec a less diverse society and that just isn't good."

Steinberg made the remarks last Friday, when politicians in Montreal's west end came togetherto speak out against the ban and vowed to organize opposition to Bill 21, which would ban some public workers from religious symbols.

At the news conference, hesaid the bill is an attempt to force minoritiesfrom the province.

"This is an attempt to remove those who practise minority religions, leaving only non-believers and Christians in Quebec," he said.

"Ethnic cleansing" is a termused to describe the forced removal of ethnic, racial or religious groups from a territory by a more dominant group.

Quebec Premier Franois Legaultwas one of many who condemnedSteinberg'scomments during the day Tuesday.

"It's unacceptable, what he said. I think he has to apologize to all Quebecers," Legault said, calling Bill 21 "reasonable."

"You may disagree, but you cannot compare to what happened to the Jewish people."

Liberal MNADavid Birnbaum, who representsthe Montreal riding of D'Arcy-McGee, saidSteinberg's comments were inappropriate and hurtful.

"I know him as a man of honourwho cares about values of equality and fairness. His words on Bill 21 were most unfortunate. They were hurtful to me and to many Quebecers. This is a society that is open and tolerant and it needs to be governed that way," he said.

Birnbaum said he continues to oppose the proposed legislation and will befighting it at the National Assembly, but that Steinberg's comments were out of line.

Liberal MNA David Birnbaum says the Hampstead mayor's comments were hurtful and inappropriate. (Radio-Canada)

Coun. Lionel Perez also weighed in on the matter, sayingthe term is used to reference violence,murder and genocide.

"I think it was a serious misjudgment,"Perez said.

While he isopposed to theproposed law, Perez said remarks such as Steinberg's have no place in Quebec society and the debate should remain civil. He said he will file a complaint with Quebec's municipal commission if the mayor doesn't apologize.

With files from Radio-Canada