Ex-mayor Michael Applebaum's lawyer argues 'many grey zones' in corruption case - Action News
Home WebMail Saturday, November 23, 2024, 11:15 AM | Calgary | -11.9°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Montreal

Ex-mayor Michael Applebaum's lawyer argues 'many grey zones' in corruption case

The fate of Michael Applebaum, the former Montreal mayor who has vowed he never took a penny from anybody, is now in the hands of a Quebec court judge, after closing arguments in the corruption trial wrapped up on Wednesday.

Applebaum, charged with breach of trust and municipal corruption, will find out fate on Jan. 26, 2017

Former Montreal mayor Michael Applebaum is accused of asking for bribes in exchange for bureaucratic favours when he was the borough mayor of Montreal's Cte-des-NeigesNotre-Dame-de-Grce neighbourhood. (Ryan Remiorz/Canadian Press)

The fate of Michael Applebaum, the former Montreal mayor who vowed that he never took a penny from anybody, is now in the hands of a Quebec court judge, after the corruption trial wrapped up on Wednesday.

Defence lawyer Pierre Teasdaledeliveredhis closing arguments, suggesting that the prosecution's case relies heavily on interpretationand that itswitnesses aren't reliable.

"There are so many grey zones. There are so many inferences we're asking you to make," Teasdale said.

"We're asking you ... to interpret what the people might have, at times, interpreted. That's extremely dangerous because it's double interpretation."

Applebaumis accused of asking for cash bribes in exchange for favours such as approved zoning changes and municipal permits during his time as borough mayor ofCte-des-NeigesNotre-Dame-de-Grce between 2006-2012.

Applebaumhas always maintained his innocence.

If found guilty, he could face up to five years imprisonment.

Crown prosecutor Nathalie Klberdelivered her closing arguments on Friday.

Judge Louise Provost is expected to deliver her decision on Jan. 26, 2017.

Defence lawyer Pierre Teasdale (left) will not be asking his client, Michael Applebaum, to testify before the court. (Radio-Canada)

Casting doubt on key witness

On Wednesday, the defence lawyer honed in on key witness Hugo Tremblay, Applebaum's former right-hand man and chief of staff at the borough.

Tremblay is the only witness who testified about where the cash, which he received from real estate entrepreneurs and engineers, ultimately ended up.

"The only witness to testify about that is Tremblay. The only one," Teasdale argued.

He suggested the former chief of staff co-operated with police and blamed everything on Applebaumbecause it allowed him to avoid any criminal charges.

But the prosecution shot back during her rebuttal that nota single witness suggested Tremblay was the important person in thealleged corruption strategy.

Klber reminded the court that real estate entrepreneur Robert Stein described Tremblay as Applebaum's "bag man" a go-between who accepted the cash on behalf of hisboss, to keep the whole arrangement at an arm's distance.

In her closing arguments, Crown prosecutor Nathalie Klber acknowledged several discrepancies in the testimony of her witnesses. 'These are details from people's memories,' she said. (Radio-Canada)

Applebaumfaces 14 charges, includingconspiracy, breach of trust and two forms of corruption: municipal corruption and fraud onthegovernment.

The Crown presented seven days of testimony from five witnesses. The defence did not call any additional witnesses, and Applebaum elected not to testify in his own defence.