Combined lanes for buses and bikes not the solution, cycling advocates say

Montreal's possible plan to add combined bus-bike lanes to some of the city's major streets is being met with skepticism by transportation experts and cycling advocates.

Mayor DenisCoderre'sadministration is considering major changes to some of Montreal's most important arteries, bytaking away a lane for cars and replacing it with a reserve lane for buses and bicycles.

• Montreal could limit cars to 30 km/h in residential areas in wake of cyclist deaths
• Where are Montreal's 10 most dangerous intersections?

Among the streets that could get an overhaul are: Papineau, St-Denis, Sherbrooke, St-Laurent, St-Urbain, Lachapelle, Rosemont and Henri-Bourassa.

Portions of some of themPapineauand deLorimier could also be turned into one-way streets.

While the plans haven't been finalized, the proposal is already facing criticism.

Designated space for bikes

One urban planner says mixing buses with bikes isn't a recipe for success.

"To have this kind of efficiency for bus use is really important. Then, of course,there's the issue of how this affects bike usersand that's a whole other conversation," said MichaelWexler, a project manageratCopenhagenizeDesign Company, a planning firm that consults cities on best practices.

Wexler, however, told CBC Montreal's Daybreak that the city is right to start looking at ways to prioritizecertain modes of transportation such as buses over cars, to encourage commuters to use public transit.

But he said designated bike lanes are a mustif the city wants to encourage cycling.

• Montreal to ramp up Bixi service with 1,000 new bikes, 80 new docking stations

That's a perspective shared by the Montreal Bike Coalition.

"If you want Montreal to become a world-class city for cycling you must provide protected intersections, especially on arteries, so that they can get to their destination directly, just as if they were driving," said Daniel Lambert, the group's spokesperson.

Creating separate sections on the road for bikes and buses carries a high price tag, however. It would also likely mean cutting into either parking or road space.

Devil in the details

MagaliBebronne, a member ofVloQubec, said research suggests ashared lane for bikes and buses can work in some circumstancesand can be dangerous in others.

The contributing factors include the width of the lane,the speed of traffic on the street andwhether there is a clear division between the areasdesignated for bikes and buses.

OnViauStreet, for instance,the shared bike-taxi-bus laneis larger than usual and divided into two a one-metre-wide bike lane on the right-hand side and a standard lane for buses and taxis on the left.

The Opposition at City Hall,Projet Montral, hasn't come out against the plans, but argues the decisions shouldn't be made in secret.

• Plateau,Rosemontmayors push city for roadsafety changes in wake of bike accidents

The debate comes following a difficult summer for cycling in Montreal, in which there were several high-profile accidents.

A panel discussionfeaturing local politicians, cycling advocates and urban planners, is took place Thursday eveningto discuss how to improve transportation safety in the city.