How the Don Dunphy case differs from previous police shootings

Man points weaponat officer, officer shoots to kill.It's an unfortunate but familiar story, but what happened inMitchellsBrook on Easter Sunday varies from other incidents in Newfoundland and Labradorthat involvedfatal shootings by police officers.

• Don Dunphy aimed loaded rifle at cop prior to fatal shooting, RCMP say
• 5 lingering questions in the fatal shooting of Don Dunphy

In the last two decades, three other men have been shot and killed by police. All three deaths resulted in judicial inquiries and legislative changes.

The provincial government isn't saying whether or not it will order a judicial inquiry into the death of Don Dunphy.

An RCMP investigation has so far found that Don Dunphy pointed a .22-calibrerifle at a Royal Newfoundland Constabularyofficer inside Dunphy's home in theMount Carmel area on Sunday.

The officer shot and killed Dunphy, 59.

There were no other witnesses.

Prior cases

Similar scenarios have played out in the past, in different parts of Newfoundland and Labrador.

On March 2, 1996,the RCMP responded to a domestic disturbance at a home in Point May on the Burin Peninsula. Inside the home, Nicholas Benteau pointed a gun at an officer. Another responding officer shotBenteau in the back, killing him.

On Aug.26, 2000, the RCMP responded to a complaint that a mentally ill man was threatening children on the Bonavista Peninsula.

Three officers showed up at Norman Reid's home in Little Catalina. Reid charged at the officers with an axe. An officer shot him five times.

Just a few months later,onOct.16, 2000,Darryl Power wasshot and killed by police in his mother's backyard in Corner Brook.

He was suicidal and had called 911 for help. When police arrived, Power came at them with knives and was killed. A judge later accepted testimony that Power brought about his own death in what is called"suicide by cop."

All three killings resulted in judicial inquiries (the Reid and Power cases were heard together) as well aschanges to mental health legislation.

In the 2000 shootings, a judge found that provincial services failed two mentally ill men,resulting in their tragic deaths.

In all three killings, a judge found that police responded appropriately.

A judicial inquiry is not automatic when police kill civilians. It's up to the justice minister to order one.

In the case of Don Dunphy, police are still investigating what happenedon Sundayand details are emerging about his background and mental health status.

Until all of that comes into focus, it's not likely that thejustice minister will determinethe need for an inquiry.