'I'm not going anywhere': Resettlement offer comes as shock to Mud Lake residents

One resident of Mud Lake, as well as legal representatives, is questioning the provincial government'smotives inoffering resettlement money for the community.

According to Watson Rumbolt, he isn't going anywhere.

"It's a job to say, 'Oh, I'm going to leave everything behind me for $250,000," Rumbolt told CBC News over the weekend.

On Thursday, theprovincial government announced it was offering up to $270,000 per household for Mud Lake residents who wishto resettle from the community, which was devastated by flooding in May2017, forcing dozens ofpeople to flee.

But Rumbolt doesn't think many are going to take the offer possiblythree or four households, by his count.

"There's already been probably four or five that's already moved," he said.

With children and grandchildren living within walking distance of his home, situatednext to the house in which his wife was born almost 70 years previously, Rumbolt is in no hurry to leave.

"As long as I got my family around me, I mean, I'm not going anywhere," he said.

Government assistance for resettling a community usuallydepends on a vote. The thresholdis75 per cent of a community's residents votingin favour of relocation.

The province sidestepped that process for Mud Lake, saying in a media release the reason is "a result of previous and potential flooding events which have been an ongoing concern for some residents" and because of the community'sgeographic location.

The province is leaving thedecision to relocate or remain in the community up to each household.

Rumbolt echoes the future floodingconcern. He said thatwhile the years since 2017 have not seen anywhere near the same kind of flooding, the fear is still there.

"Every one of us, I think, in Mud Lake is worried about it. [We're] more or less scared every spring, wondering what's going to happen," he said.

Questions needing answers

The offer of resettlement money comes during the ongoing class-action lawsuit brought against Nalcor Energy by residents of the area, alleging that the flooding was connected to the Muskrat Falls hydroelectric project just up river.Nalcor Energy has since been absorbed into N.L Hydro.

A 2017 independent assessment of the flooding concluded that the event was not due to Muskrat Fallsbut natural causeswith unusually heavy rainsand ice blocking the mouth of the Churchill River.

Halifax lawyer Ray Wagner, who is representing Mud Lake in the lawsuit, sees the offer as an admission of responsibility and liability for what's happened.

"I'm happy to hear that they're going to do the right thing," said Wagner.

But he saysthere was no communication to residents or legal counsel before the offer of resettlement funds and, assomething their lawsuit was asking for to begin with, it came as a shock.

"We don't know what that means," Wagnersaid."We have no idea how to quantify these issues. There's a whole host of questions that need to be answered."

Rumbolt sees a line between resident'scomplaints and resettlement money offered against "potential risks that may occur in the future,"as Municipal Affairs Minister Krista Lynn Howellsaid in Thursday's media release.

"I think that they're offering us this to try to get everybody to move, so that way if something happens they don't have to deal with Mud Lake no more," said Rumbolt.

Read more from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador