At Canada's largest Atlantic puffin colony, chicks are dying of starvation

The volunteers who rescue Atlantic puffin chicks called "pufflings" knew something was wrong when so few strays from the Witless Bay Ecological Reserve on Newfoundland's Avalon Peninsula showed up this summer.

The fledglings emerge from their burrow at night to avoid predators, but some are attracted to the lights in the rapidly growing communities on shore. Members of a group called the Puffin Patrol capture the stranded pufflings and release them into the ocean.

"The Puffin Patrol wasn't finding very many birds," said Sabina Wilhelm, a wildlife biologist with Environment and Climate Change Canada.

"And the birds that were being found were actually very small in body weight."

Some were less than half the normal size for puffins their age.

After searching a sampling of nests on the ecological reserve where Atlantic puffins congregate to breed each spring, Wilhelm and her colleagues discovered that many chicks had perished.

The grim discovery connects the fate of the Atlantic puffin which is not only the official bird of Newfoundland and Labrador, but aubiquitous image in the province with serious problems in ocean ecology, including warming ocean temperatures and a struggling, complex food web.

'They died of starvation'

Tests ruled out avian flu, which caused a massive die-off of birds in 2022.

"Just based on the the body mass and just picking up the dead chicks, that were just skin and bones, so essentially they died of starvation."

Adult puffins dive for food such as capelin, a forage fish that can make up as much as 50 per cent of their diet, and bring it back to the nest, a burrow in the cliffs.

But when food is scarce the adults feed themselves, and the chick is left to starve.

Another anomaly is that puffins bred later this year, Wilhelm said.

"Normally they start fledging in early August and by the end of August, early September, most of them are gone," she said.

"There seems to have been this mismatch between breeding activity and the fact that capelin kind of disappeared.... Other years there might have still been a lot of capelin in August. That just didn't happen this year."

Warmer ocean temperatures also work against Atlantic puffins, who can dive to a depth of only 50 metres to catch capelin and other forage fish such as sandlance and herring.

"So if the fish are moving downwards into the water column because the waters are warmer, then suddenly ... they're not accessible to the puffins anymore because they can't dive that deep," Wilhelm said.

With more than 300,000 nesting pairs breeding at the Witless Bay Ecological Reserve, the Atlantic puffin population is robust overall, said Wilhelm.

Because they live well into their 20s, losing their offspring in one year does not spell disaster for the species. But the starvation of so many Atlantic chicks this year is a concern, Wilhelm said.

When tour boat operator Joe O'Brien noticed dead chicks floating on the water, he alerted Wilhelm and her colleagues.

O'Brien, a former fisherman, has been bringing tourists to the Witless Bay Ecological Reserve for 39 summers.

With so many species, from cod to seabirds to whales, relying on capelin for their survival, O'Brien says it'stime for a new approach to managing this fishery.

"Should we be harvesting capelin at all?" O'Brien asked. "Shouldn't that be a sign to to management that we should change our philosophy respecting the ocean?"

The Department of Fisheries and Oceans categorizes the capelin stock as "critical," yet it allowed a commercial fishery of 14,533 tonnes in 2023 for the second year in a row.

In its capelin management plan, DFO said, "Science shows the fishery's impact on capelin is small compared to predation by other species such as seabirds, cod and other fish."

Capelin are caught using a purse seine, which surrounds the fish, corralling them into the net and tightening it, similar to a drawstring, before it's hauledaboard a fishing vessel.

However, the species is a mere fraction of its abundance in the 1980s. As the principal food for cod, capelin overfishing is recognized as one of the key factors in the collapse of northern cod stocks more than three decades ago.

Valued for its eggs, or roe, female capelin is exported to China, the United States, Taiwan and Japan.

In the 2023 season, capelin sold for an average of 16 cents a pound, netting $4.5 millionto fishermen in landed value, making it one of the least lucrative fisheries in the province.

"We're destroying them in mass volumes ... only taking the females.... That's crazy," O'Brien said.

"Why are we catching one of the main sources of food for just about everything in the water?"

Capelin fishery 'incomprehensible'

Ian Jones, a marine bird biologist at Memorial University, is also concerned about the impact fishing capelin has on the entire ecosystem.

"When I hear these claims that somehow you can keep fishing a forage fish like this ... it's incomprehensible to me," he said, adding that the fisheries "arguably don't bring in a whole lot of money."

The effects of fishing a forage species, a rapidly warming ocean due to climate change, increasing amounts of artificial light, seabird huntingand monofilament fishing netsare cumulatively stacked against seabirds' long-term survival, Jones said.

While Atlantic puffins can sustain some mortality because of their abundance, the Leach's storm petrelhas seen a decline of about 50 per cent in recent years, hesaid.

"We haven't seen a bird disappearing at this rate since the passenger pigeon," Jones said.

Like the Atlantic puffin, the Leach's storm petrel is also affected by a growing amount of artificial light from communities, boats and offshore oil installations.

"These seabirds that have evolved to survive in one of the harshest environments on Earth are faced with this completely disorientating artificial light," Jones said."They don't successfully get out to sea so they basically strand on land and and die in very large numbers."

'Canary in the coal mine'

The United Nations calls light pollution "a significant and growing threat to wildlife" that contributes to the death of millions of birds globally.

WATCH | Seabirds face multiple threats:

Thousands of Atlantic puffins die in North America's largest puffin colony

12 months ago

Duration 2:10

Researchers believe climate change could be partly to blame for thousands of dead Atlantic puffins in Newfoundland, as warming ocean temperatures force the seabirds to dive deeper and deeper to find fish, leaving many to starve to death.

Seabirds that migrate at night and go off course chasing artificial light are at risk of becoming exhausted, being eaten by predators, or colliding with buildings.

The impact of warming ocean temperatures is already being found in other Atlantic puffin populations.

"The worry is, is that these puffins are going to experience the same fate here in Newfoundland that they're experiencing in the Eastern Atlantic," Jones said, "with year after year of no chick surviving, the population begins to crash and then in some areas disappear."

Seabirds are a great indicator of the health of the ecosystem, Wilhelm said, andO'Brien saidthe puffin is warning us that the ocean is under stress from climate change.

"The puffin is acting like the canary in the coal mine."

Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Click here to visit our landing page.