CBRM committee overseeing port development rarely met, lacks records - Action News
Home WebMail Sunday, November 10, 2024, 10:18 PM | Calgary | 0.3°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Nova Scotia

CBRM committee overseeing port development rarely met, lacks records

Depending on who's being asked, a Cape Breton Regional Municipality committee that's supposed tooversee a proposed container terminal development has either met within the last couple of months or sometime in 2022. There's no written record of it ever having metand no one can say who chairs the committee, whose detailsare as murky as the future of the Sydney Harbourterminal.

Clerk's office says no list of meetings, no minutes kept for committee struck nearly 3 years ago

A breakwater of rocks juts out into the water of Sydney harbour, with grasses and trees in the foreground.
The CBRM Steering Committee of Sydney Harbour Investment Partners is supposed to oversee development of a container terminal on a piece of land in Sydney Harbour, shown here. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

Depending on who's being asked, a Cape Breton Regional Municipality committee that's supposed tooversee a proposed container terminal development has either met within the last couple of months or sometime in 2022.

There's no written record of it ever having metand no one can say who chairs the committee, whose detailsare as murky as the future of the Sydney Harbour terminal the project it's meant to champion.

One of its members, Coun. Eldon MacDonald, said he couldn't provide a lot of information about the committee or its meetings.

"I'm going to suggest it's probably a year and a half or possibly more, but we didn't meet very often," he said.

The committee was struck in 2021 while council was considering a contract extension with Sydney Harbour Investment Partners, orSHIP, and now known as Novaporte.

A man with a white beard and moustache wearing a dark blue suit looks toward the camera.
Coun. Eldon MacDonald says he can't recall for sure, but he believes the committee did not meet to discuss the developer's switch from a container terminal to offshore wind. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

Several councillorshad complained about a lack of information coming to council from the developer, and it was suggested a committee might be easier to assemble for a meeting with company CEO Albert Barbusci.

But MacDonald said CBRM has instead "gone back to that format of getting updates at council."

Novaportepursuing other options

Last month, Coun. Darren Bruckschwaiger expressed concernsthat Novaporte has switched its focus to offshore wind turbine marshalling,especially since the contract with CBRMis specificallyfor a container terminal and not for any other business venture.

MacDonald said he couldn't recall whether Barbusci brought the offshore wind idea to the steering committee or to council as a whole.

"It's been so long since the steering committee has really met as a steering committee that I don't think we've met since the wind opportunity presented itself," he said. "If we have, then I stand to be corrected."

He said there had beentalkof having the container terminal contract amended to include offshore wind development, but "where that is, I couldn't speak to that."

Mayor Amanda McDougall said recently that the steering committee met with Barbusci a couple of months ago, so everyone was aware of his plans to pursue offshore wind turbine marshalling.

A man in a charcoal grey suit with glasses speaks to someone off camera with a Canadian flag in the background.
Coun. Lorne Green agrees with Coun. Eldon MacDonald, saying the steering committee has not met in at least 18 months and says he's not the chair and doesn't know who is. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

Coun. Lorne Green, who's on the committee, said he didn't think that meeting took place.

"Unless it's an email that I missed or overlooked, but not to my knowledge, no, we haven't met," he said.

"We get emails from SHIP, as council as a whole, on updates that are going on. That would be about the only updates we are receiving."

Informationon port 'sparse,' says councillor

Green said he could notrecall when the committee met last, but it was at least 18 months ago.

He also said the information coming from the port developer has been "sparse."

"It's a concern, obviously, because we've got an agreement with [an]individual to get a container terminal happening at Sydney Harbour and it doesn't seem to be happening."

Greencould not speculateon why the committee hasn't met lately, saying he's not the chair and couldn't say who is.

MacDonald said no one was ever named chair.

The committee's third member, Coun. Steve Gillespie, said in an email he wasn't sure ifthere were any minutes from meetings "or if the group is even a committee or just an advisory group."

No record of meeting minutes

According to the minutes of a June 2021 council meeting, the "CBRM Steering Committee of Sydney Harbour Investment Partners" was created "to assist in the advocacy and the work required to move the project forward."

However, there is no record of any committee meetings or minutes, according to the clerk's office, despite requirements in the Municipal Government Act for meeting dates to be listed publicly and minutes kept, even if the meetings are held behind closed doors.

Two women, one with red hair and glasses and one with brown hair, put their heads together looking at something behind a computer screen.
CBRM clerk Christa Dicks, left, is seen with Mayor Amanda McDougall. Dicks says her office was never asked to set up steering committee meetings or take minutes for them. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

Clerk Christa Dicks said there is no record of the steering committee's workbecause heroffice"has not been engaged for involvement."

The contract to develop CBRM's land in Sydney Harbour is up in November.

MacDonald said he has no problem with the switch in focus to offshore wind turbine marshalling, because it would require a wharf and infrastructure beneficial for a container terminal.

At that point, a terminal would just require a rail line somethingMacDonald said he thinks is still possible, even though the provincial government has ended a subsidyintended to keep the existing rail line in place.

Green said without that subsidy, it's an open question whether a container terminal project will ever come to CBRM.

However, both he andMacDonald saidif the land can be used for offshore wind marshalling, they're comfortable with a new council deciding on a contract extension or a new contract with Novaporte after this fall's municipal elections.

Add some good to your morning and evening.

Get the latest top stories from across Nova Scotia in your inbox every weekday.

...

The next issue of CBC Nova Scotia newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in theSubscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.