Hammonds Plains woman taking developer to court over flooding, property damage - Action News
Home WebMail Wednesday, November 13, 2024, 05:00 AM | Calgary | -1.4°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Nova Scotia

Hammonds Plains woman taking developer to court over flooding, property damage

A woman in Hammonds Plains, N.S., says a new development next to her property has led to flooding and other damage on her property, so she's taking the developer to small claims court.

Developer says they offered to fix issues but received no response

A golden and black dog walks through dark pools of water amongst trees, with a large wooden unit sitting to the left
Tammy Broussard's family dog walks through a flooded area in the rear of her backyard on Pockwock Road on Oct. 20, 2023. A storage unit she says has been damaged by water sits to the left. (CBC)

Tammy Broussard watches her dog wade through a pool of water in her backyard where she once mowed grass, steps away from a fire pit she no longer uses.

Broussard said the creation of anew seven-unit housingdevelopment next door has led to flooding and other damageon her Hammonds Plains, N.S., property, so she's taking the developer to small claims court.

"We've lost a lot because of this development," Broussard said in an interview."We have nobody, nobody to advocate for us."

A white woman with shoulder-length dark blonde hair wears a jean jacket and teeshirt. She stands outside in a yard, with a home behind her
Broussard says she is not happy with how the neighbouring seven-unit housing development has damaged her land, so she is taking the developer to small claims court. (Robert Short/CBC)

The issues started last summer, she said, when trees and a thick stand of bushes along the side of her front lawn were removed, revealinga view ofthe back decks on the new condosat 85 Pockwock Road.

Over the next few months, Broussard regularly contacted the Halifax Regional Municipality about issues she saw: the missing bushes, a gravel driveway the developer built on her land, as well asdecks and awningsthat encroached on the property line.

A small excavator sits on the left side of the property line, on Broussard's land, appearing to move earth as piles of infilling sit beside it.
Construction equipment is seen working on the seven-unit condominium development by Benmark at 85 Pockwock Rd., right, sometime in late 2022. The small wooden stake in the foreground marks the property line for Broussard's property. (Tammy Broussard)

She said city staff eventually told the developer to shorten the decks and awnings, which they did. But Broussard said she wasn't happy with overall communication from the municipality.

Broussard said staff told her the issue was a civil one between neighbours, and she could also contact police. She made a complaint to RCMPinJune, but the Mounties told CBCNews the matter was acivil land dispute so the investigation was closed.

The biggest issue wasflooding. Broussard said the developer raised the grade of their property and filled in a longstandingstorm-water trench that ran behind both properties, creatinga dam.

"We haven't been able to utilize our backyard for the better part of well, two summers," shesaid.

In April, Broussard said she had a meeting with two Halifax staff members and two of the development's contractors. They told herthey planned to install a drainage system to handle watercollectingalong theproperty line between the buildings, and that she could choose what trees and shrubs would be replanted on her land to fix the damage.

Broussard said while the drainage system works well, it was placed under her property and she doesn't want the responsibility of maintaining it.

A view from up high shows muddy water in a trench at the back of the property, with clear water spreading outwards and covering more than half the backyard and submerging a firepit
Flooding in Broussard's backyard from February 2023. (Tammy Broussard)

Just before historic flooding hit the province in July,shecalled the provincial Department ofEnvironment and Climate Change to inspect her property.

Theresulting report from environmental officer Anthony Heggelin said that on July 13, he saw water up over the fire pit areaas well as debris like leaves and tree needles further up the lawn marking where previous flooding had reached.

Heggelin wrote that the waterway in the backyard was drainage, and the neighbouring property "appeared to have blocked/altered the drainage flow when they developed the property."'

A screen of green bushes is seen between the properties, with some gaps so the home on the left could be glimpsed now and then. The lot on the left is overgrown with tall grass
A view from Google Street View of the area between Broussard's home at 87 Pockwock Rd., left, and 85 Pockwock Rd., captured in September 2021 before the Benmark development got underway. (Google)
There are some scattered trees and brush along the property line, but the home on the left is much more open to the street and neighbouring property. A flattened gravel area is between the properties, to the left of a one-story blue building
A view from Google Street View of the area between Broussard's home at 87 Pockwock Rd., left, and the Benmark development at 85 Pockwock Rd., right, captured in July 2023. (Google)

Although Broussard said they offered to sell the developer the strip of land between their properties, they declined. So, Broussard said there was "no other avenue" but to file a lawsuit in small claims court for $25,000 to cover some of the damages.

"We're going to be hard pressed to find anybody who would even want to stay here to rent the place even, let alone buy it," Broussard said."You know, your home and your property are your biggest assets."

Developer responds

Ontario-based Benmark Residential Investments is building the row of condos. Mark May and Benjamin May are listed as the company directors.

In a statement via their lawyer Will Brien of Cox and Palmer, Benmark said they have acted "in a respectful manner within the neighbourhood" and operated under the full oversight of HRM for the building and grading of the development.

Benmark acknowledged they inadvertently damaged "a small patch of grass and shrubbery" onBroussard's property, and allowed a short piece of pipe to be placed partially onto herland as part of the drainage system.

"Benmark has made several offers to remediate and fix this damage to ensure that the Broussard's property is fully repaired to its original state and that the Broussards are happy. In spite of our best efforts, through multiple channels, we have yet to have a reply to our offer from the Broussards," Benmark said.

Funds sent to Halifax as bond for work

The developer added theyprovided an "undertaking and bond" to the municipalityto do remediationwork on Broussard's property. According to Benmark's statement of defence, that meant depositing the "required funds" with Halifax staff to addressBroussard's "genuine concerns."

The defence claim also said the municipality directed Benmark to change the historic cross-property water flow at the rear of 85 Pockwock Road down the property line with the Broussards' to a ditch on the main road.

They said that "misdirection from HRM" caused the pooling of water, but the Broussard propertyalso hasa "deep low area" atthe rear that historically flooded. They also said they had never installed a driveway or culvert on the property.

A view of the tall, beige city hall as seen from an angle. The stone building has a large clock tower in the centre
The Halifax municipality says it 'continues to work with the developer' in this situation and cannot offer specific comments while that work is ongoing. (Robert Short/CBC)

When asked whether the municipality has issued any fines or warnings to Benmark, a spokesperson for HRM said the city "continues to work with the developer and cannot provide any specific comments with respect to this matter while that work is ongoing."

Brynn Budden, a spokesperson for the municipality,also wrote that it is not part of the small claims court case, andcannotcomment on Benmark's point that Halifax directed them to change the original drainage direction.

Broussard's two-day court hearing with Benmark is set for December.

Halifax-area woman takes developer to court over property damage

12 months ago
Duration 2:34
The company in question is building a condo development next to her home, but during the process they crossed her property line. The company says they offered to fix the issues, but the homeowner says it's not enough. Haley Ryan has the story.

Add some good to your morning and evening.

Get the latest top stories from across Nova Scotia in your inbox every weekday.

...

The next issue of CBC Nova Scotia newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in theSubscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.