I asked more than 50 Sask. residents what matters to them in this election. Here's what I discovered - Action News
Home WebMail Thursday, November 14, 2024, 01:08 AM | Calgary | 6.7°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
SaskatchewanAnalysis

I asked more than 50 Sask. residents what matters to them in this election. Here's what I discovered

What actually matters to Saskatchewan residents in this month's election? More than 50 people CBC spoke to in five communities explained why health care, education and cost of living matter most to them.

Ahead of Oct. 28 election, people told CBC why education, health care and cost of living are top of mind

A collage shows people from multiple ethnic backgrounds.
CBC spoke to more than 50 people in Weyburn, Estevan, Fort Qu'Appelle, Regina and Lumsden to ask what issue mattered most to them in the provincial election. Pictured from top left, clockwise: Merissa Scarlett, Pasqua First Nation Chief Matthew Todd Peigan, James Carty, Allister Watson, Nadine Goodwill, Asha Shivarajan, Arlene Low and Miranda Hanus, centre. (CBC)

What actually matters to Saskatchewan residents in this month's provincial election? If the 50 regular voterswerecently talked with are representative, it's health care, cost of living and schools.

I'll admit, talking with random strangers isn't easy. When I walk up to a stranger on the street, my gut clenches and I have to force a smile. But it's important, and the insight it gives CBC is valuable.

That's why I've spent the last couple of months asking Saskatchewan people what's most important to them, both in an online form that solicited more than 150 responses from across the province,and in conversations on the street in towns and cities across southern Saskatchewan. I visited five communities, going into different spaces from a powwow ground to a parental rights meeting.

While some people just shrugged and said they hadn't been paying attention or didn't plan to vote in the Oct. 28 election, there were three consistent themes that came up wherever I went.

I got a glimpse into how people are navigating their day-to-day livesand how they hope the next government will help tackle the issues of health care, education and cost of living to make their lives better.

A stretched health-care system

Brenda Andrews, 64, wrote to CBCvia our online form, sayingshe hadn't been able to see an ophthalmologist for her complex glaucoma. She'd also struggled with walking, and after a few months of not having the issue properly diagnosed or dealt with, she paid for an MRI scan in the U.S. to get to the root of the issue, she said.

"We paid all our working lives into the health-care system. Now it is not there for us,"said Andrews, noting her rural hospital in Kamsack has dealtwith a loss of services and beds in the past few years.

"In my opinion, medicare is dead we just haven't buried it yet."

Several people hold signs calling for better health-care staffing.
People hold signs outside the Saskatchewan Legislative Building during a rally organized by Saskatchewan Union of Nurses in Regina on Thursday. (Heywood Yu/The Canadian Press)

It's not a problem among just seniors either. I spoke to first-time voter and college student Allister Watsonin Estevan, who said with complex health needs, health care was top of mind for him as well.

"My medical appointments are usually long trips halfway across the province that get fairly expensive for gas and food and hotels. And it's all of that for a 20-minute appointment that could have been done over, like, a video call," he said, noting this means missing school and seeing his grades suffer.

"It wears on me."

Shay Millard is currently on maternity leave from her role as a registered nurse in a Regina hospital operating room, but she saw the stresses on the health-care system from the other side.

"We're the Level 1 trauma centre in the city, and it's really hard to get coverage and appropriate staffing," she said.

"You pick up more [on-call shifts] than is possible for one person and it's just a lot of overtime and a lot of long shifts, late nights."

The province has recruited several Filipino health-care workers to come to Saskatchewan staff she described as "fantastic" but she believes retention will remain an issue unless conditions are safer, less stretched and less toxic for health-care staff.

"People are leaving because they're overworked, and it's not conducive with a family-life balance. So they're leaving places like the O.R. where we need their expertise, because [there's] a lot to learn there."

WATCH|Frustrated nurses describe working conditions on CBC'sBlue Sky:

2 Saskatoon ER nurses speak frankly about a health-care system they say has never been so bad

3 days ago
Duration 14:19
Two Saskatoon nurses say the health-care system is at a breaking point and that they need to speak out about what they are seeing. Sarah Peters, a veteran ER nurse at Royal University Hospital, and Stephanie Fehr, an ER nurse at St. Pauls Hospital, talked with Blue Sky host Leisha Grebinski.

At Weyburn's Culture Days, registered nurse Asha Shivarajansaidshe's seen Canadian citizens skipping long wait lines and going back to India to get treatment for illnesses like cancer.

For her, the top election issue is getting people's qualifications assessed more quickly, to alleviate the stress on the health-care system.

"I got my RN licence just recently in 2024, 10 years after I passed my RN exam from Ontario. But since they had so much trouble with recognizing my RN licence from a different province in the same country, it took me 10 years," she said.

She hopes to see her friends with nursing backgrounds avoid having to jump through multiple hoops to get their skills assessed.

Finding the money to live

I ran into Kayleigh Pearce from Pense while out at the Lumsden Duck Derby in August. When I asked her husband what his top issue was, Pearce was quick to jump in and listoff their family's rising power and grocery bills.

"With trying to feed five kids they're growing [and] we want them to be healthy and happy. But if it's going to be the difference between a car payment and feeding my kids, no family should have to go through that," she said.

WATCH |Sask. mother of 5 says cost of living is her top election issue:

Sask. mother of 5 says cost of living is her top election issue

9 hours ago
Duration 2:00
Kayleigh Pearce, a mother of five from Pense, describes the cost-of-living challenges middle-class families are facing in Saskatchewan. In the lead-up to the provincial election, she's watching for which political party lays out a plan to make life more affordable.

She and her husband both have decent-paying jobs, but Pearce said she wasn't sure how others who weren't so fortunate could make ends meet.

"It's ridiculous," she said."Right now,as parents, we're planning to hopefully be able to afford a big enough house so our kids can live with us until they're 25 if they need to, and that sucks."

I noticed that Pearce wasn't alone in thinking of the future, particularly when it came to the cost of living and housing. If things are bad now, what might they be like for future generations?

Deborah Cookson said she may have a home herself, but she has young grandchildren who are struggling with what she called "outrageous" rents.

"By the time you pay that, you pay your food, you pay your gas and you pay your bills, whatever else, they can't ever save any to put the down payment down," she said, as she stopped along her walk at the legislative grounds in Regina.

"I don't want them to have to suffer the rest of their lives and not be able to get a nice house someday."

A woman with dark-rimmed glasses stares into the distance.
Miranda Hanus from Regina said she could see how easily people could slide into homelessness, having seen for herself how hard it was for people to find an affordable place to live. (CBC)

Just being able to find a rental can be a challenge for many. Regina's Miranda Hanus said that when her old home flooded, she struggled to find a place that didn't have pests, was in a decent neighbourhood and would be affordable.

"At one point I was actually looking into that option, sleeping in my car, if worse came to worse," she said.

Hanuswas able to find a place that cost her $800 a month, but saidothers are not so lucky, and she can see how easy it would be to slide into homelessness.

Education concerns

I was surprised by how many times people listed "education" as their major election issue, including those who weren't teachers or parents of school-age kids. That was the case for a couple of university students I caught up with during the University of Regina's move-in day.

A dark-haired woman with black sunglasses on her head leans forward, with a street visible in the background.
Principal Arlene Low works in Davidson and is concerned that the outlook for future educators is bleak. (CBC)

"I'm passionate about students and teaching, but I worry about the younger generation, the new teachers that are coming into the profession," said Arlene Low, a school principal fromDavidson who was helping her child move into the university for the first time.

"I feel like there's so much pressure on them and they don't have the supports that they need."

Estevan Public Youth Centre executive director Merissa Scarlett said she could see the impacts of COVID-19 and interruptions on learning every day in her job. Some kids she sees struggle to write their own name, she said.

"From my job, I see 11-to 17-year-olds who have a hard time reading and writing and if you can't read or write, you're going to have a hard life," she said, noting those missing skills could have a knock-on effect in other areas of a young person's life, from their mental health to finding a job.

A group of young people hold signs while standing in front of a marble-columned building.
Students rally outside the Saskatchewan Legislative Building in Regina on April 12, 2024, in a show of support for teachers whose contract expired in August 2023. (Kirk Fraser/CBC)

Theyear-long contract disputebetween teachers and the government appeared to leave a bitter taste in voters' mouths, particularly for those who are educators or who identified themselves as relatives of educators.

Is any one issue enough to sway change?

While health care, education and affordability repeatedly came up as crucial topics, most voters didn't seem to have a clear answer on which party was best placed to address these issues.

First Nations voters I spoke to at a Treaty 4 celebration in Fort Qu'Appelle expressed a real sense of disconnect with politicians, who were seen by and large as not honouring treaties and doing little more than paying lip service to things like truth and reconciliation.

"The government has to take some responsibility for their actions and move forward," said Nadine Goodwill from Standing Buffalo Dakota Nation. She said she hoped to see more action from politicians on sharing land and resources equally with First Nations people, as promised in those treaties.

Governments need to sit down and talk with First Nations people to address key issues like climate change, according to Pasqua First Nation Chief Matthew Todd Peigan.

A man with white hair and ribbons along his shirt looks into the distance, with children seen behind him.
At Treaty 4 anniversary celebrations, Pasqua First Nation Chief Matthew Todd Peigan said he hoped to see different levels of government sit down with Indigenous people to address the critical issue of climate change. (CBC)

"Sadly, our mindset has strayed to more materialistic and greed, rather than working together, living as one people, and looking after Mother Earth," he said.

For all the time and energy politicians have spent arguing against the carbon tax, not one person I spoke to on the streets raised the carbon tax as a top election issue. Only a few rated the climate as their top election issue, even after another hot and smoky summer, and moretemperature records being broken across Saskatchewan.

After 17 years of unbroken SaskatchewanParty electoral success, the big question is whetherany other party can make a dent in its support base.

One farmer in Weyburn put that exact question back to me. As someone with two children, both of whom have special needs, his number 1 issue was education and ensuring his children's needs would be met.

However, he noted, Weyburn has been represented by the Sask. Party since 2006, and for him personally, no one issue was going to change how he voted. He wondered out loud is any given issue likely to sway voters to opt for change in this year's election?

As always, that's up to voters when they mark their ballots on Oct. 28.