Federal environment minister calls Premier Moe 'immoral' for flouting carbon-price law

Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault says Ottawa has to take action against Saskatchewan for breaking the federal carbon-pricing law.

Premier Scott Moe said last week Saskatchewan would not submit the money it owesfor the carbon price on natural gas as required on Feb. 29.

Moe is protesting Ottawa's decision to exempt heating oil from the levy but not natural gas, which is used by eight in 10 households in Saskatchewan.

Under the law, fuel distributors such as SaskEnergy are to submit monthly reports on the amount of fuel sold and the carbon price collected on that fuel.

Failing to submit those reports or pay the amounts owed carries consequences, including fines based on how much wasn't paid and jail time.

Guilbeault says it is "immoral" and "irresponsible" for a premier to decide not to follow the law.

"If Premier Scott Moe decides that he wants to start breaking laws and not respecting federal laws, then measures will have to be taken," Guilbeault said in response to a question from a reporter.

WATCH | Premier Scott Moe says Saskatchewan will not back down in its scrap with Ottawa over carbon taxes

Premier Scott Moe says Saskatchewan will not back down in its scrap with Ottawa over carbon taxes

6 months ago

Duration 1:55

While thousands of teachers were picketing outside the legislature, Premier Scott Moe began his morning outlining the government's labour market strategy. It was the unofficial kickoff to the opening day of the sitting which ended up returning to a familiar debate.

"We can't let that happen. What if somebody tomorrow decides that they don't want to respect other federal laws, criminal laws? What would happen then if a prime minister, a premier of a province, would want to do that?" he went on.

"It's irresponsible and it's frankly immoral on his part. We can have disagreements about things like climate change, but to be so reckless is unspeakable, really."

On Monday, Moe reiterated thefederal carbon-pricing law should be eliminated.

"It isdriving inflation and we still are paying agood chunk in other areas and the position from the government of Saskatchewan's perspective hasn't changed nor will it change. It should be removed on all products for all," Moe said.

Last week, SaskEnergy Minister Dustin Duncan said he knew there might be consequences to his government's decision, but that it came out of a sense of fairness.

"It's not something I take lightly," Duncan said Feb. 29.

Last fall, the federal Liberals moved to give heating oil a three-year carve-out from carbon pricing, arguing families using that product needed more time and financial aid to replace their oil furnaces with electric heat pumps.

Heating oil is about three times as expensive as natural gas, before carbon pricing, and oil prices jumped more than 50 per cent in recent years, providing a financial incentive to replace it without the addition of a carbon price.

WATCH | Sask. government says tax agency recognizes it as sole distributor of natural gas:

Saskatchewan government says tax agency recognizes it as sole distributor of natural gas

7 months ago

Duration 2:02

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has agreed to a request from the Saskatchewan government, naming the government as the province's natural gas distributor rather than SaskEnergy, a provincial Crown Corporation. The decision comes as Saskatchewan continues to resist the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act (GGPPA), a federal law that requires the collection of the federal carbon tax.

Federal data shows 1.2 million homes in Canada still use heating oil, and almost one-quarter are in Atlantic Canada. Only three per cent of those are in the three Prairie provinces.

The Liberals were accused of making the decision based on politics, with their poll numbers on the East Coast tanking. The governing party has few seats in the Prairies, but a majority of seats in the Atlantic.

It could be a while before any consequences are known.

While Saskatchewan has been very public about not making the payment, for privacy reasons, the Canada Revenue Agency will not confirm when a specific client fails to submit a payment on time even if it is a provincial government.

The CRA does have compliance processes for seeking payment or documentation before turning to the courts.

Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson said last week one consequence will be cutting the carbon rebates sent to Saskatchewan households.

The rebates are based on how much money is collected in each province, and will be lowered, he said, if less money comes in.