Home | WebMail | Register or Login

      Calgary | Regions | Local Traffic Report | Advertise on Action News | Contact

SudburySWEENEY TRIAL

Steven Wright found guilty in Rene Sweeney murder

Steven Wright has been found guilty of stabbing 23-year-old Rene Sweeney to death in a Sudbury video store on Jan. 27, 1998.

Verdict comes after five weeks of trial, four years since the arrest and 25 years since the murder

A balding man with a thin beard wearing a light brown shirt looks into the camera
Steven Wright, 43, was first arrested for murder in December 2018, some 21 years after Sweeney was murdered. (Facebook)

Steven Wright has been found guiltyof stabbing 23-year-old Rene Sweeney to death in a Sudbury video store on Jan. 27, 1998.

The jury delivered its verdict in the Sudbury courthouse on Wednesday afternoon, after deliberating for a little more than a day.

A cheer went up from the side of the courtroom where the Sweeney family was sitting and people hugged each other with tears in their eyes.

There were also tears in the eyes of Wright's mother, and his father gave a meek wave, as theywatched their 43-year-old son be led out of the courtroom by police officers.

This follows some five weeks of testimony in one of the most anticipated murder trials in Sudbury's history. And it comes some 25 years after the murderand four years after Wright was first arrested and charged with murder.

Two women stand outside in the snow outside of the Sudbury courthouse
Rene Sweeney's sister Kim (right) and family friend Kelly Irvine both spoke about Rene's mother Carole in court Friday, noting that her multiple sclerosis got much worse after the murder and that in later years she was treated by Steven Wright's mother, who worked as a home care nurse. (Erik White/CBC)

WithRene's sister Kim standing next to her grinning, family friend Kelly Irvine told reporters that they were"thrilled" and"ecstatic" with the jury's decision.

"Rene Sweeney got justice today after what horribly happened 25 years ago," Irvine said.

Defence lawyer Michael Lacy didn't take questions from reporters, but in a statement, repeated his belief that the Crown's closing statement earlier this week misrepresented the evidence heard in court and may have misled the jury.

"You know this case screamed out for reasonable doubt. And I can only assume that what happened wasthe jury was affected by what we say was a very improper closing," he said.

"Of course there's also appellant level courts that may have to take a look at this case now, as a result of the Crown conduct."

Rene Sweeney smiles and looks straight into the camera, with dark hair surrounding her face.
23-year-old Rene Sweeney was stabbed to death in January 1998 while working in a Sudbury video store. (Supplied)

Asked for reaction, Crown prosecutor Robert Parsons said:"I guess that's something Mr. Lacy will deal with. I was content with the closing that the Crown presented, which is probably the best I can say about it."

He said he was pleased that the jury "didn't rush,"took their time to consider the evidence anddidn't think "anybody was terribly surprised" that all 12 found Wright guilty.

Asked what it was like to speak with Kim Sweeney after the guilty verdict came down, Parsons said moments like that are what "gets you through long nights working to get ready for a trial like this."

"It's the reason Crown attorneys do what Crown attorneys do frankly," he said.

Two lawyers wearing black robes speak to reporters outside a courthouse
Crown prosecutors Kevin Ludgate and Robert Parsons speak to reporters after the jury delivered its guilty verdict. (Erik White/CBC)

Sgt. Robert Weston, who was the final lead investigator on the case for the Sudbury police, said he was always confident that they would eventually catch the killer.

"This investigation has been in the public's eye and in the face of the Sudbury Regional Police andGreater Sudbury Police for 25 years," he said.

"We had the evidence, we just needed to match it up to a person, it was just a matter of when."

During the trial, the defence pointed to numerous errors made by Sudbury police in the murderinvestigation, including not properly protecting forensic evidence from contaminationand falsifying notes, but Weston didn't think that tainted this day for the police force.

"Mistakes are bound to happen. We faced them, we admitted them and we accepted them and moved forward," he told reporters.

A man with short-cropped hair, wearing a blue suit speaks to reporters outside of the Sudbury courthouse
Sgt. Robert Weston was the last lead investigator on the Rene Sweeney murder case for Sudbury Police. (Erik White/CBC )

The next step is a sentencing hearing, which has yet to be scheduled and which will be presided over by Justice Robbie Gordon.

Second-degree murder comes with an automatic life sentence, but Gordon asked the jury for their opinion on the earliest date Wright should be eligible for parole, and they all voted for between 20 and 25 years.