Why Kathleen Wynne seems poised to prorogue Ontario Legislature - Action News
Home WebMail Saturday, November 23, 2024, 10:04 AM | Calgary | -12.0°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
TorontoAnalysis

Why Kathleen Wynne seems poised to prorogue Ontario Legislature

Few government bills are working their way through the legislature, and those that are could be passed within a few weeks, clearing the decks for prorogation.

Prorogation would take spotlight away from opposition, clear decks for Liberal cabinet shuffle

Asked 'Are you going to prorogue?' Premier Kathleen Wynne laughed and replied, 'Stay tuned.' (Marta Iwanek/Canadian Press)

This story started to emerge when I was getting my hair cut.

In the basement of Queen's Park, there's a tiny barber shop, run for decades by now-semi-retiredFrank Filice, who has cut the hair of more Ontario politicians than anybody.Frank doesn't reveal what they talk about.

But last week, after Frankfinished with me, PC House Leader Jim Wilson sat down in the chair, started chatting in a barbershop sort of way, and ended up telling me, "I think they're going to prorogue."

Prorogation matters, because in essence it meansshutting down the legislature. It's perfectly within the government's right, but it can be controversial: It kills any bills that are yet to be passed, stops committees from working and robs the opposition of its daily chance to hold the government to account in question period.DaltonMcGuintyprorogued in October 2012, with his minority government under siege over the growing gasplants scandal.

So why would Premier KathleenWynne prorogue now?Wilson is a veteran of the legislature and knows how things work from both the government and opposition perspectives.

So his theory triggered me to dig further. And what I found convinced me:It sure looks like Wynnewill prorogue, likely by the end of April. Here's why:

1. Short list of bills

There are very few government bills working their way through the legislature. The only major pieces of legislation that are yet to be passed are the budget, the cap and trade rules, and the new bill onemergency responders suffering frompost-traumatic stress disorder. Those bills could become lawwithin a few weeks, clearing the decks for the government to proroguewithout hurting any of its keyinitiatives.

Prorogation means shutting down the legislature. It terminates bills that are yet to be passed, stops committees from working and takes away the daily spotlight of question period. (Bruce Reeve/CBC)

2. Early budget

Finance Minister Charles Sousa delivered the budget exceptionally early this year, on Feb. 25. None of the government's explanations made sense.

"It's important for us to come out early in order for us to achieve success in some of the investments that we're proposing," Sousa said.

"We want to make sure that it's clear to everyone as early as possible what the next steps are going to be," said Wynne.

A reasonfor tabling the budget earlythat would make sense?To get it passed quickly, to thenprorogue.

3. New faces in an old government

Wynne's cabinet is overdue for a shuffle. Every single minister she namedafter winning the 2014 election remains in place.

But cabinet shuffles while the legislature is sitting have their disadvantages. Ministers new to their portfolios would love to have extra time to get up to speed on the issues, without the pesky daily probing of question period. Prorogation would give them that time.

PC House Leader Jim Wilson believes the Liberals will prorogue Queen's Park soon after the budget bill passes, likely in April.

4. Looking ahead to an election

It's coming up to two years since Wynne won her majority. Pretty much everything laid out in her government's 2014 throne speech has been accomplished. It would make sense to do a reset, with a new throne speech and new voter-friendly initiatives aimed toward the 2018 campaign.

A prorogationcould last indefinitely but it would be unlikely to last longer than the fall. Proroguingwould also, conveniently, reduce PC Leader Patrick Brown's opportunities to boost hisprofile among voters byhammeringthe Liberals during question period.

5. No denials

In the hours before the Sunshine List was released last Thursday, Wynne had a news conference. Nearly all the questions were about the list of Ontario's best-paid public servants. I decided to try to catch her by surprise.

"Are you going to prorogue?" I asked.

Wynne smiled, laughedand responded: "You know what? There is a lot more work to do in the province, so stay tunedfor how we're going to continue to build this province up."

She didn't say no. My question and Wynne's refusal to deny itturned intoa news story.

So will prorogation happen? Sure looks like it.As Wynne said,"Stay tuned."