Ontario could face Charter challenge over law forcing some elderly hospital patients into nursing homes

Health-care advocates say they are preparing a possible constitutional challenge to an Ontario law that allows some discharged elderly hospital patients to be forced into a nursing home they did not choose.

Natalie Mehra, executive director of the Ontario Health Coalition, describes the More Beds Better Care Act as "fundamentally discriminatory" against the frail and elderly.

Bill 7 passed in late August and came into effect Sept. 21, but the full scope of the law was only realized Sunday when one of itsmost controversial components kicked in. Ontario hospitals are now required to charge a mandatory fee of $400 per day to dischargedpatients who refuse to go to a long-term care home arranged on their behalf.

Mehra says there is currently no way to appeal if patients are forced somewhere they don't want to go.

"We're going to take it to the courts and ask the courts tostrike it down," Mehra says.

WATCH | Dr. Samir Sinha told CBC News Network he supportstheconstitutional challenge. Here's why:

Geriatric specialist welcomes constitutional challenge to Ontario's Bill 7

2 years ago

Duration 4:15

Dr. Samir Sinha, director of geriatrics at Sinai Health and the University Health Network in Toronto, approves of health-care advocates' constitutional challenge of a new Ontario law that could force some elderly hospital patients to move to a long-term care home they didn't choose.

Patients could wind up 70 km away in southern Ontario

She says details of the planned legal fight will be revealed at a joint news conference Monday co-hosted by the Advocacy Centre for the Elderly.

The province has said the law is meant to help ease pressures onhospitals that have been overwhelmed by emergency visits andsurgical backlogs.

The rules apply to hospital patients deemed by doctors to need an "alternate level of care" who have been placed on a wait-list to get into a long-term care home. The province said there are about 1,800 such patients across the province.

Mehra says there are 38,000 people on the waitlist for long-term care.

She says Bill 7 allows hospitals or discharge planners to override patient consent to secure a bed as far as 70 kilometres away in southern Ontario and 150 kilometres away in northern regions. If there are no beds available, Mehra says the law allows northern residents to be sent even further afield.

"The only long-term care homes that would have beds available at all are ones that have terrible reputations for care or are very far away," she says.

'Fundamentally discriminatory,' advocate says

"We've looked through the waitlist all across Ontario to see which long-term care homes have the lowest waitlist and those will be the places. They include the homes that the military went intoduring the (COVID-19) pandemic and found just horrific conditions."

If people end up falling sick because of that, they would end up in hospital and then be discharged to a long-term care facility they don't want, she says.

"We're talking about pushing people out of hospitals to die. I mean, let's get real," she says.

"It's targeting the frail elderly. We believe it's fundamentally discriminatory and ageist and there are other solutions. It's justthat the government will not do that."