Canada's COVID-19 response better than many comparable countries, study finds

Canada handled the first two years of the COVID-19 pandemic and weathered the ensuing upheaval better than several other nations with comparable health-care and economic infrastructure, a new study suggests.

The research, published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal on Monday, credits Canada's strong performance to restrictive and persistent public health measures as well as a successful vaccination campaign.

A team of Ontario researchers compared data from February 2020 to February 2022 in 11 countries dubbed the G10 due to the late inclusion of one subject. They analyzed data from Canada, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States all countries with similar political, economic, and health-care systems.

"If you look at Canada compared to the G10, the differences are enormous," study co-author Dr. Fahad Razak said in a recent interview.

"If you look at our vaccination rate, we had the highest in the entire G10, we had the lowest number of people infected and lowest of people dying."

The research suggests Canada's cumulative per-capita rate of COVID-19 cases was 82,700 per million, while all countries with the exception of Japan were above 100,000 per million. Canada's rate of COVID-19related deaths was 919 per million, once again second-lowest behind Japan. All other countries were over 1,000 per million.

Raywat Deonandan, an epidemiologist and associate professor at the University of Ottawa who was not involved in the study, said the methodology of the research is sound, even if it can be challenging to compare infections and deaths across jurisdictions.

"Bottom line: Canada's relatively strict approach resulted in fewerinfections and deaths," Deonandan said in an email.

WATCH | Expert explains how Canada fared comparablywell in the pandemic:

Canadian public health measures made 'big difference' against COVID-19, expert says

2 years ago

Duration 5:01

A new study in the Canadian Medical Association Journal suggests Canada's public health response to the COVID-19 pandemic was better than many similar countries. Montreal cardiologist Dr. Christopher Labos agrees, saying Canada did well when considering factors like mortality and vaccination rates.

'Persistent level' of restrictions

Razak said at least 70,000 more Canadians would have died during the first two years of the pandemic if Canada had the same death rates as the United States, the country with the highest cumulative number of COVID-19-related deaths.

"That means most of us would probably personally know a grandparent, or a friend or family member ... who's living today in Canada who would have died if we had the same trajectory as the United States," Razak said.

He said Canada's comparatively positive outcomes came about despite gaining access to vaccination later than most countries, noting there were also other health-care system structural disadvantages to overcome across the country at the outset of the pandemic.

"Some hospitals were so overwhelmed that we had to ambulance or airlift patients to other hospitals," he said.

But Canada, he said, differed from other developed countries when it opted to implement public health measures that were both strict and persistent. Though such measures drew vehement opposition in some circles, Razak said they helped mitigate the pandemic's overall impact.

"Compared to many other countries ... they would have periods with tight restrictions but quickly pull back," he said. "For Canada, it was really this high and persistent level almost entirely for the first two years."

Highest proportion with two doses

Razak said the success of Canada's immunization drive emerged as the strongest takeaway from the research, praising officials for engaging with the population and ensuring vaccines were readily available across the country.

More than 80 per cent of eligible Canadians have been fully vaccinated with two doses as of June. The percentage of the vaccinated populations in other G10 countries is between 64 and 77 per cent, according to the study.

"There was a magic in Canada around these vaccine roll-outs during dose one and dose two," Razak said.

"When we speak to our colleagues across the world, Canada was the envy of the world in terms of our population rallying around this. It is a lesson to the world, that very high engagement can occur with the right strategy."

Dr. Eleanor Fish, an immunologyprofessorat the University of Toronto who was not involved in the study, said the findings were consistent with her own assessment of the pandemic in Canada.

Like Razak, she said the population's high vaccination rate played a major role in the country's strong performance.

WATCH | Dr. Theresa Tam on timing of boosters:

COVID-19 boosters 'likely' needed around end of this year, Dr. Tam says

2 years ago

Duration 8:42

Canada's chief public health officer, Dr. Theresa Tam, speaks to CBC chief political correspondent Rosemary Barton about where Canada is with COVID-19, her thoughts on vaccine boosters and what she's watching for when cooler fall temperatures return

Fish also cautioned that there could be challenges ahead this fall, when COVID and other respiratory illnesses are likely to put a strain on thehealth-care system.

"We should be planning for that now," said Fish.

Economic burden

The study also showed the countries' response to the pandemic left an economic burden, with government debt rising for all countries and Canada registering one of the highest relative increases.

"We had these very significant economic impacts, we had very tight restrictions on our individual freedom which led to things like isolation ... but we also had really among the best results in terms of controlling the impact of the virus," Razak said.

"Was it worth it? That's not a scientific question. That's a values and morals and policies question."