Intel breakdowns and 'black holes': How foreign interference became a political flashpoint

Parliament is set to rise for the summer in a few weeks but the contentious debate over foreign interference is likely to continue.

Despite facingcalls to step aside, David Johnston tasked by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau back in March with looking into allegations that China tried to meddle in the past two federal elections has said he plansto continue his work.

Johnston will be holding a series of public hearings over the summer. He'llface MPs'questionswhen he appears beforea House committee Tuesday morning.

The allegations

Citing unnamed national security sources, the Globe and Mail and Global News have reported that Beijing has deployedoperations meant to influence and interfere in Canadian politics includingthe 2019 and 2021 elections.

Those operations allegedlyhave included attempts to intimidate and influence members of Parliament andfundpolitical candidates, and the operation of so-called "police stations" acrossCanada meant to intimidate dissidents and members of Chinese diaspora communities.

The Globe also reportedthat a Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) documentstatedthat Beijing attempted to orchestrate the election of a Liberal minority government in 2021.

In March, Global published a story alleging that former Liberal MP Han Dong who is currently sitting as an Independent advised a senior Chinese diplomat in February 2021 that Beijing should hold off on freeing Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor, the two Canadians being held by China at the time. Dong has refuted those claims and is suing Global for $15 million.

The Globe, citing a top secret document from 2021, also reported last month that the Chinese government was targeting a Canadian MP. An unnamed security source reportedly told the Globe that Chinese diplomat Zhao Wei was allegedly working on efforts to target Conservative MP Michael Chong's family in China.

In his first report,released last month, Johnston disputed Global's reporting on Dong and the Globe's report on Beijing workingto ensure a Liberal minority in 2021. He saidthose media reports misconstrued top-secret intelligence because it lacked a broader context.Johnston also said that additional context could not be shared publicly.

Johnston reportedhe did find evidence that Chinese officials contemplated taking unspecified action against Chong and sought to build a profile on him, although there's no evidence they threatened either Chong or his family.

The MPs affected

CSIS has briefed two other MPs about foreign interference.

Both former Conservative leader Erin O'Toole and NDP MP Jenny Kwan said last week that CSIS has informed them they've been targeted by Beijing.

O'Toole told the House of Commons that CSIS informedhim that he has been an ongoing target of a Chinese government campaign of misinformation and "voter suppression" that covered the last federal election campaign.

WATCH | O'Toole rises in House on foreign interference

'Our Parliamentary democracy must be defended': O'Toole rises in House on foreign interference

1 year ago

Duration 0:54

Conservative MP Erin O'Toole spoke about the briefing he received from CSIS after he was told he was the target of foreign interference during the last election.

Kwan told reporters Monday that CSIS told her she is an "evergreen" target of Beijing. Both O'Toole and Kwan said China's government is singling them out over their vocal support for democracy in Hong Kong and for religious and cultural minorities in China.

Former Conservative MP Kenny Chiu has blamed Beijing's alleged election meddling for losing his seat in the 2021 election. He claims he was the target of propaganda and disinformation on WeChat a Chinese-owned messaging app that falsely claimed his private members' bill would unfairly target the Chinese community.

Chiu's bill actually proposed to establish a foreign agent registry that would require non-elected individuals to declare when they receive money from foreign governments.

Chiu was critical of Johnston's first report. He said it didn't consultdiaspora communities affectedby foreign interference something Johnston has promised to do during his public hearings taking place this summer.

But some Chinese Canadians are calling for immediate action rather than more hearings.

WATCH | 'The time for action is now,' advocate says

Chinese Canadians say they dont need public hearings to tell them what they already know

1 year ago

Duration 8:10

Cherie Wong, Executive Director of Alliance Canada Hong Kong talks to Power and Politics about her organization's newest report detailing foreign election interference in Canada.

"We can't wait for a 12 to 16 month process to tell us something that we already know," Cherie Wong, executive director of the Alliance Canada Hong Kong (ACHK), told CBC News Network's Power & Politics last week.

Wong said members of the Chinese-Canadian community feel they have been talking about foreign interference for years without government action. She pointed out that her organization released reports on foreign interference in 2020, 2021 andthis year.

"We don't need another person to tell us there's foreign interference. We don't need another person to study the tactics. We have studied it and we have presented it in this beautiful report," Wong told CBC's David Cochrane.

Johnston's first report

In his report, Johnston did conclude that foreign governments are attempting to influence political candidates and voters, and that more needs to be done to combat these attempts. But the former governor general ultimately advised against calling a formal public inquiry to investigate foreign interference, triggering outrage amongopposition parties.

Johnston suggested that a formal public inquiry would not serve to investigate allegations of foreign interference in the 2019 and 2021 federal elections because much of the classified information he has reviewed would need to remain secret.

While much of the public attention has been focused on Johnston's decision not to call for an inquiry and hispersonal connections to the prime minister, hedid flag issues withintelligence.

Specifically, Johnston criticized the wayintelligence agencies, including CSIS and the Communications Security Establishment (CSE), share intelligence with the federal government.

"The materials are disseminated, but no one keeps track of who specifically received or read them," Johnston wrote in his report. "This means there can be intelligence that is 'sent' to various consumers, but it does not always actually get consumed."

Johnston saidstaff at the Prime Minister's Office told himthey're given a large binder in a secure room to review secret material, with no ability to take notes for security reasons.

Johnston said thatbinder covers a rangeofintelligence topics from around the world and no one tells PMO staff to concentrate on one topic or another. If staffers are away, he said, they may not see the binder that day.

Johnston said he also found evidence that Chinese officials contemplated taking unspecified action against Chong in 2021 and sought to build a profile on him. Testifying beforea House committee last week, Trudeau's national security adviser Jody Thomas saidthere has been a "breakdown" in how intelligence is shared in the government and used Chong's case as an example.

Thomas said CSIS sent a memo in July 2021 to three deputy ministers across government, but the message effectively went into a "black hole."

How much is Johnston being paid?

Johnston is receiving a per diem in the range of $1,400 to $1,600, according to the Order in Council that announced his appointment.

CBC also has reported that Johnston hired the crisis communications firm Navigator to support himand taxpayers are footing the bill.

What has the government done so far?

In 2017, the government set up the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians (NSICOP), a bipartisan assembly of MPs and senators who are sworn to secrecy in order to receive top-secret briefings.

Trudeau has asked the committee to look into foreign interference. Their classified reports are sent to the prime minister before a redacted version is made public.

During a committee appearance last month, Chong called for NSICOP to be brought under the purview of Parliament so it can be answerable to the House, rather than the prime minister.

The government established the Critical Election Incident Public Protocol in 2019 to monitor and alert the public to credible threats to Canada's elections. The team is a panel of top public servants tasked with determining whether incidents of interference meet the threshold for warning the public.

A report reviewing that task force's work was released in February.Itsaid that interference didn't affect the outcome of the 2021 vote. But it did recommend that the government lower the threshold for alerting the public to potential interference attempts.

The government also established the Security and Intelligence Threats (SITE) task force in 2019,a bodyconsisting of representatives of Canada's top security agencies. SITE has met regularly since 2019 and now meets on a monthly basis; its meeting become more frequentas elections draw near.

During his speech last week in the House, O'Toole criticized both task forces for failing to tell himhe was a target.

In the wake of the revelations about Chong, Trudeau said he's told CSIS to share more information about potential threats to MPs.

Last month, the government expelled Zhao Wei, the Chinese diplomat accused of targeting Chong and his family.

Recently, the RCMP said it has "shut down illegal police activity in Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia" connected to so-called Chinese "police stations" but it hasn't said whether it has made any arrests.

The government is also planning to introduce legislation this year to establish a foreign agents registry.

Under a foreign agent registry, people who act on behalf of a foreign state to advance its goals would have to disclose their ties to the government employing them.