Twitter shuts out German neo-Nazi group's account

Twitter has for the first time blocked an account using a new tool that allows it to bar content in individual countries, shutting out a banned German neo-Nazi group at the behest of local authorities.

Twitter spokesman Dirk Hensensaid an email Thursday that the account @hannoverticker has been blocked only in Germany, where its content is considered illegal.

"At the beginning of the year Twitter announced the so-called 'country withheld content' function, which enables us to remove illegal content in a particular country while leaving it available for the rest of the world," he said.

"In doing this we place great value on transparency; in the case of the account @hannoverticker we used this function for the first time."

For further details, he pointed to the Twitter account of the company's general counsel Alex Macgillivray, who said in a tweet that the site's administrators "never want to withhold content, good to have tools to do it narrowly and transparently."

Group banned by local government

The @hannoverticker account is used by a fringe far-right group, Besseres Hannover Better Hannover, which Lower Saxony's state government banned last month on the ground that it was promoting Nazi ideals in an attempt to undermine German's democracy.

In a letter posted by Twitter, Lower Saxony authorities asked the company to "close this account immediately and not to open any substitute accounts for the organization Besseres Hannover."

The letter said the regional Interior Ministry's ban included an order for "the closure of all user accounts of the Besseres Hannover group."

Because of its Nazi past, Germany has strict laws prohibiting the use of related symbols and sloganslike the display of the swastika, or saying "heil Hitler."

YouTube account, website also shut down

Lower Saxony Interior Ministry spokesman Frank Rasche said the ban applied to Besseres Hannover's entire online presence and that similar letters were sent to YouTube which also complied and the U.S.-based Internet service provider that hosted the group's website.

That site also seemed to be down Thursday, though Rasche said he was not aware of any reply from the ISP.

"The Web page is hosted in the U.S.A., and that is difficult because it is known there that extreme right speech is not criminal as it is here," he said. The last tweets on the now-blocked Twitter account came on the day Besseres Hannover was banned, Sept. 25. In that, the group equated living in present-day Germany with being "rudely awoken and finding yourself in East Germany"a communist dictatorship.

When accessing @hannoverticker from Berlin on Thursday, there was a simple notice saying "this account has been withheld in: Germany."

Twitter announced the blocking function in January, insisting its commitment to free speech remains firm, despite global outrage that the social media tool of choice for dissidents and activists was being limited.

In this case, Kirsty Hughes, chief executive of the Britain-based free speech advocacy group Index on Censorship, said Twitter's decision was more about German laws prohibiting extreme right speech than the social media company's policy.

"We would argue it is perfectly fair to ban speech that is direct incitement to violence, but not to ban speech that is just extreme and doesn't incite violence," she said.

"However many years after the second world war, the question is, is it still appropriate, and whether it was ever appropriate (in Germany)that's the source of this decision today, rather than Twitter being where one should point the finger."