California Republicans fight the sanctuary state - Action News
Home WebMail Thursday, November 14, 2024, 04:07 AM | Calgary | 6.6°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
World

California Republicans fight the sanctuary state

California is set to become the U.S.'s first sanctuary state, barring police from enforcing the president's immigration policies. But some jurisdictions that support Trump are fighting back.

Bill to limit enforcement of federal immigration laws would 'give our state away'

California, where many cities thumb their noses at Trump's immigration policies, is set to become the U.S.'s first sanctuary state. But some jurisdictions that support the president are fighting back. (Kim Brunhuber/CBC)

If you're looking for Trump voters in California, look for the oil wells or the farm crops. And when you see both in the same field, you're probably inKern, the biggest Republican county in the state.

Sitting around a table at a mini-mall in the county seat of Bakersfield, a couple of old friends complainabout "illegals." They're thrilled that the U.S. president is fulfilling his promise to crack down on them.

There's too many people up there that are too liberal that are willing to give our country away or our state away.- RonReece, Bakersfield resident

"You don't let people invade your country!" says Ron Reece.

"It's whoever wants what for free gets it," says George Henderson. "I earned mine, let them earn theirs!"

Since Trump signed an executive order tightening border security, the number of illegal immigrantarrests is up 38 per cent over the same period last year, according to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

Reece, a former cop, says illegal immigrants who commit crimes have been coddledby state politicians in the capital, Sacramento.

"There's too many people up there that are too liberal that are willing to give our country away or our state away," Reece says.

Kern County, 220 km north of Los Angeles, is one of the most Republican areas in California. (Kim Brunhuber/CBC)

Exhibit A, he says, is a bill that's set tomake California the nation's first sanctuary state. The law would forbid police from investigating, detaining or arresting people for immigration enforcement purposes.

Trump also signed an executive order that would cut federal funding to so-called sanctuary cities, but a U.S district judge in northern California imposed a nationwide injunction against it.

SalTinajero, a city council member in Santa Ana,72 kilometres south of L.A., says if Trumpwants to deport California's estimated 2.4 million illegal immigrants, he's going to have to"find them himself."

But Santa Ana gets about a fifth of its money from Washington. And according to Tinajero, since it became a sanctuary city in January, one form of federal funding has already been cut.

Santa Ana city council member Sal Tinajero is eager for California to become a sanctuary state. He says if Trump wants to deport the state's illegal immigrants, he'll have to 'find them himself.' (Kim Brunhuber/CBC)

"We have a jail here that houses about 120 ICE detainees. So all of a sudden two weeks ago we got a notification that they're no longer going to use our beds. Those are the kind of funds he can take away," Tinajero says.

Becoming part of a sanctuary state, he says, means Santa Ana won't have to face down the feds alone.

"It is a great, great protection for us smaller cities because we then know that we're all in this together," Tinajero says.

World 'full of terrorists'

But some Trump-supportingcommunities say it's unfair that their local approach to law enforcement will be overridden by the state, and they're pushing back.

"We're not looking for a fight with the federal government," says KernCounty Sheriff DonnyYoungblood.

In April, Youngbloodpushed for a resolution declaringKerna "law and order" county, rather than a "sanctuary" county.

"If we don't work with our federal government, some of these criminal immigrants that are here illegally will be released back in our community and create more victims," Youngblood says."We live in a very serious world full of terrorists who want to come in and destroy us. And people don't want us to have a secure border.... This isn't about race, it's about safety."

However, not everyone is clear what sanctuary actually entails. A common misconception is that it means sanctuary from prosecution.

"If you're a criminal, you shouldn't be walking in the streets," says Bakersfield resident Evelyn Nyitray. "And no one should be able to say 'Oh it's OK because he's an illegal.'"

Retiree Dave Smith agrees.

"It's to a point now where immigrants in a sanctuary city or sanctuary state have more rights than the citizens do," Smith says.

'They could just take me'

Advocates for the sanctuary state say it's about more than just signaling tolerance. It's about protecting undocumented workers from being persecuted by police, and encouraging them to co-operate with authorities without fear of being deported.

Still, the prospect is little comfort toCitlallyFigueroa, whose familyimmigrated illegally from Mexico when she was two.

"The government has the information so they can essentially find us," says the 24-year-old who will graduate university in June. "If ICE has a warrant for my neighbour, they can come and take him, and if I'm there, they could just take me. It's really hard for me because I tried really hard and" she pauses to wipe away tears "I thought maybe it would pay off."

Kern County Sheriff Donny Youngblood wanted to introduce a motion that would declare Kern a 'non-sanctuary' county. (Kim Brunhuber/CBC)

And even though SanJoseis essentially a sanctuary city in what could soon be a sanctuary state, immigration lawyer Diana Morales says it's unclear what exactly that means.

"Because we don't know how executive orders and the memorandums are going to be implemented, we are not totally sure how sanctuary cities are going to work," says Morales, of the Services, Immigration Rights and Education Network (SIREN). "We're going to protect you, but protect you from what? We don't know for sure what that protection will entail."

Country is 'so fragmented'

The uncertainty is affecting communities on both sides of the divide.

InKern, officials like County Supervisor David Crouch saythey can't win. Trump has signaled his intention to go after jurisdictions that don't co-operate with federal immigration. But if California's sanctuary bill passes, the state could cut Kern's funding over that co-operation.

"Now we will have the federal government saying one thing with regard to this, and we'll have the state government saying an entirely other thing," Couch says. "So what would you do?"

With more than a dozen states contemplating sanctuary state measures, and nearly twice as many having introduced bills to ban them, the conflict may ultimately be decided not by politiciansbut by judges, says USC immigration law professor Jean Reisz. She says the establishment of a sanctuary state is significantbecause states' rights are much more powerfully enshrined in the Constitution than those of cities.

"The federal government can't withhold funds to coerce a state into carrying out the federal laws," Reisz says.

But state's rights are a double-edged sword: they can also be used to curtail sanctuary cities.In Texas, the governor recently signed a bill that would prohibit them. Soon, any Texas law enforcement official who doesn't co-operate with federal immigration could go to jail. Opponents have filed a federal suit challenging the law.

Santa Ana, Calif., officials say the city has already seen funding for its immigration jail cut since it declared itself a sanctuary city. (Kim Brunhuber/CBC)

And they have a surprising ally: Youngblood.

"The way California has put sheriffs in the middle, or the way Texas is putting sheriffs in the middle, is wrong," says Youngblood, president of the California State Sheriffs' Association. "If you're in Texas and you're not co-operating with ICE, you're in jeopardy. In California, if you are, you're in jeopardy. It just doesn't make logical sense that our country is so fragmented."