Whether it's strategy or revenge, Israel is likely to prevail in Gaza offensive but then what? - Action News
Home WebMail Thursday, November 21, 2024, 04:53 PM | Calgary | -10.8°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
WorldAnalysis

Whether it's strategy or revenge, Israel is likely to prevail in Gaza offensive but then what?

Israel's well-trained and well-equipped army will almost certainly prevail in any ground incursion into Gaza even if, experts warn, such a huge operation risks worsening and widening the current conflict.A key question, however, remains unanswered: What happens after a military victory?

Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant told ground troops Thursday to be ready for the order to invade

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu sits in a  chair in front of several Israel flags, answering questions.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu listens as he and U.S. President Joe Biden participate in an expanded bilateral meeting with Israeli and U.S. government officials on Wednesday in Tel Aviv. (Evan Vucci/The Associated Press)

"Now is a time for war," declared Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu last weekamid signs a major ground invasion of Gaza was being planned.

OnThursday, Israel looked determined to carry out that promise asIsraeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant told ground troops to be ready for the order.

"Whoever sees Gaza from afar nowwill see it from the inside," he said. "I promise you."

Israel's well-trained and well-equipped army is likely to prevail, although experts say such a huge ground operation risks worsening and widening the conflict.But one key question remains unanswered, said Dahlia Scheindlin, an Israeli political analyst and pollster in Tel Aviv:What happens after a military victory?

Men in army uniforms hold guns
Israeli soldiers listen to Israel's Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, during his visit to a staging area near the border with the Gaza Strip in southern Israel on Thursday. (Tsafrir Abayov/The Associated Press)

"There is no doubt in my mind there are figures in the government and the military asking the same question," she said. "And I am not at all sure they do have answers."

There has already been more than a week of Israeli airstrikes on Gaza,killing at least3,785 Palestinians and wounding 12,500, the Hamas-run Health Ministry in Gaza said on Thursday.

Israel says its main target is Hamas, the militant group responsible for the surprise attack on Oct. 7in which morethan 1,400 people in Israel werekilled,including several Canadians. About 200 peoplewere taken as hostages to Gaza.

The unexpected timing and unimaginable violence left Israel angry and shaken.

A woman stands in front of lighted candles
A woman stands in front of lighted candles in honour of victims of the Hamas attacks during a vigil at the Dizengoff square in central Tel Aviv on Wednesday. (Petros Giannakouris/The Associated Press)

What could happen on the ground?

Some in Israel worry the offensivewould be motivated mostly by a desire for revenge.

"I think that's the primary driver of this willingness to tolerate our casualties and to go into a major, major military operation," said Benjamin Miller, a political science professor at the University of Haifa.

The desire for retribution is strong among the public and even among some military and political leaders, he said.

WATCH | Protests over Gaza hospitalexplosion:

Gaza hospital explosion sparks protests across the Middle East

1 year ago
Duration 3:26
People across the Middle East and the Arab world protested a deadly explosion at a Gaza hospital, rejecting Israel's claims it was not responsible.

Nizar Farsakh, a former advisor to the Palestinian leadership in the West Bank, who now teaches international affairs at George Washington University,chalks it up to fear.

"Part of the brutality that you're seeing from Israel is precisely because they're petrified," he said. "They just realized that they are completely ill-equipped to face Hamas."

Destroying Hamas may mean sacrificing many Israeli soldiers.

Observers say the militant group has between 20,000 and 30,000 fighters, no match for Israel's advanced army. But Hamas has the advantage in urban fighting because of its familiar home turf and a network of tunnels they'vebuilt over 16 years, through repeated confrontations with Israel.

"Undoubtedly, they're setting traps for the Israeli soldiers," said Nomi Bar-Yaacov, an analyst with the London think-tank Chatham House. "Gaza is likely to look like a bloodbath" if they try to fight their way in, she said.

Hamas has been getting ready for this for so long, said Farsakh, it "probably prepared something that defies or goes outside of the imagination of the Israeli intelligence agencies."

What will happen to Hamas?

The most senior Hamas leadership isn't in Gaza;it's in the Gulf, said Janice Stein, professor of conflict management at University of Toronto's Munk School of Global Affairs. And she says Hamas will be hard to dislodge because it is as much a movement as it is a political party, with community roots.

"You can't wipe out social movements," she said.

But in practical terms, it is also the administrator of Gaza.

Hamas has governed Gaza and its 2.3 million residents since it split with itsPalestinian rival Fatah and seized control of the territory in 2007, prompting Israel's ongoing blockade of the territory.

Two men sit in chairs with flags propped between them.
In this picture released by the Iranian Foreign Ministry, Iran's Foreign Minister Hossein Amirabdollahian, left, meets with Ismail Haniyeh, one of the leaders of the Palestinian militant group Hamas, in Doha, Qatar on Oct. 14, 2023. (Iranian Foreign Ministry/The Associated Press)

If it is eliminated, who would run Gaza on a day-to-day basis? The Palestinian Authority, which administers the occupied West Bank, has not had a significant presence or popular support in Gaza since it was evicted by Hamas in 2007.

As for Israeli forces, "it would be very costly for Israel to hold Gaza forever," said Miller. It would also presenta much bigger challenge: The population in Gaza is more hostile to Israel than it is in the West Bank, and it includes more Islamic fundamentalists.

What will happen to Palestinians?

For Palestinian civilians, the implications of a major ground offensiveis expected to be as devastating as the current air campaign, especially if it involves heavy fighting in urban residential areas.

Already, "Palestinians are traumatized," said Farsakh.

Rescue workers carry a child out of a pile of rubble.
Palestinians evacuate wounded from a building destroyed in Israeli bombardment in Khan Younis, Gaza Strip, on Thursday. (Fatima Shbair/The Associated Press)

Many may notlike Hamas's policies, he said, butmost would "stand in the rubble of their own houses and cheer the fighters on" out of the frustration of no change in their circumstances in decades and a feeling they need to "up the ante."

"Palestinians are the ones that are feeling the urgency most, and therefore, they are the ones that are supporting desperate initiatives," said Farsakh.

They also feel this reminds the world the issue is still unresolved and relevant, he said.

Some Israelis are certainly thinking about that fact again, said Scheindlin.

"As long as the military conflict is unresolved and people's national self-determination is denied," there will never be a normal life in Israel, she said.

Others on the political right, Scheindlin said, will conclude "the only option we have is a complete military destruction of Palestinian political leadership and military capacity and total control over Palestinians."

Can Netanyahu regain public trust?

In the face of the Hamas attack, Israel's society has united, broadly backing this government's direction for the first time since it was elected a year ago.

But just under the surface, there is a feeling of "abandonment and betrayal" from a leadership that was caught by surprise by Hamas, said Scheindlin.

"There's an enormous sense of breach of trust between the people and the state," she said, "including the security establishment and the vaunted IDF(Israel Defence Forces)."

If the invasion fails to achieve its goal, if it takes too long or if Israeli casualties are too high support will evaporate, said Miller.

People hold signs that say bring back out kids and bring them home
Families and supporters of Israelis held captive in Gaza call for their release during a demonstration in Tel Aviv Wednesday. The Israeli army says some 200 people were kidnapped and taken to Gaza in Hamas's cross-border attack on Israel on Oct. 7. (Petros Giannakouris/The Associated Press)

Already, families of the missing have organized demonstrations in front of Israel's Defence Ministry in Tel Aviv, holding placards reading "Shame!" and pictures of victims.

"I want to make sure that it's loud and clear that the first priority should be bringing [the hostages] home," said one protestor, Inbar Ravid.

The last time Israel had to deal with a hostage situation in Gazaitinvolved just one captured soldier, Gilad Shalit. A ground incursion by the IDFfailed to find him, and he was eventually exchanged for more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners let out of Israel's jails in 2011.

WATCH | Red Cross trying to gain access to hostages:

Red Cross trying to gain access to Hamas hostages

1 year ago
Duration 1:49
Sarah Davies, with the International Committee of the Red Cross, says her organization is in contact with Hamas and is 'relentlessly' seeking access to the hostages held by the militant group. The Red Cross wants to 'create a lifeline of communication' for families desperate for news.

Managing the rescue or release of some 200 Israeli hostages, and dealing with the expectations of their families and the country, will be even more contentious for a government already under fire. And it may overreact in order to try to regain public trust, said Farsakh.

"So, they're trying to create as much casualties on the Palestinian side to show the Israeli government is answerable to the Israeli citizens," he said.

There was a political split among Israelis even before Oct.7. Anger over legislation to overhaul the judicial system to give politicians greater power over judges laws introduced by Netanyahu and his ruling coalition of ultra-nationalists sparked months of huge demonstrations across the country.

A woman embraces a body covered in an Israeli flag.
Antonio Macas's mother cries his body covered with the Israeli flag at Pardes Haim cemetery in Kfar Saba, near Tel Aviv, on Sunday. Macas was killed by Hamas militants while attending a music festival in southern Israel on Oct. 7. (Francisco Seco/The Associated Press)

Pollster Scheindlin says the split and the anger have only been "reinforced" by the war.

That leads Stein to conclude, "Netanyahu is finished."

His right-wing allies, including hard-line settler groups, are being blamed for focusing too much of the army's attention on the West Bank, she said. The implication would be a shift toward the political centre, said Stein.

Outrage in the Arab world

Look no further than the Arab world's reaction to a single event the hospital blast that is said to have killed hundreds of Palestinians in Gaza City this week and it's easy to imagine the outrage an all-out Israeli invasion would spark.

It's a "dark and dangerous abyss" into which the region could be pushed, said United Nations Mideast peace envoy Tor Wennesland at a Security Council meeting this week.

A girl, her face covered in mud and tears, sits in a corridor with a woman, who is also crying.
Wounded Palestinians at the al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City, central Gaza Strip, on Tuesday. (Abed Khaled/The Associated Press)

After the explosion at Al-AhliArab Hospital, each side pointed at the other. Palestinian officials blamed an Israeli air raidwhile Israel said the blast was caused by a failed rocket launch by the Islamic Jihad militant group, which denied responsibility.

People protested from Tunis to Tehran. In Amman, Jordan, police pushed an angry crowd back from the Israeli embassywhile in Beirut, security forces fired tear gas and water cannons at protesters near the U.S. embassy.

The Iran-backed militant group Hezbollah called for "a day of unprecedented anger" from its base in southern Lebanon. Observers are watching the group closely for signs that it might use the opportunity of Israel's focus on Gazato attack from the north.

IN PHOTOS |The protests:

Iranitself has threatened action against Israel if it doesn't stop its "genocide of Palestinians," using an alliance of militant groups called the Axis of Resistance. It includes Hamas and others in Lebanon, Syria and Iraq.

There has long been popular sympathy for Palestinians at street level throughout the Middle East, even as "normalization agreements"with Israel have been signed by several government in the region. Those agreements have included barely a nod to Palestinian rights, with no insistence on the two state solution an independent Palestinian state next to the Israeli one.

A similar normalization agreement was being negotiated in earnest between Saudi Arabia, Israel and the U.S. when this conflict broke out one with the potential of "transforming the Arab-Israel conflict," said Robert Satloff, a Mideast expert with the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.

WATCH | How Lebanon clashes could escalate the war:

Why clashes on Israels border with Lebanon could escalate the war

1 year ago
Duration 6:37

Bringing together Saudi Arabia, "the custodian of the two holy mosques in peace with the Jewish state would be the ultimate affirmation of Israel's presence in the Middle East," he said.

Now, talks with Israel have been put on hold by Saudi Arabia, made politically unpalatable by the war.

But while Israel is accused of being too aggressive by some in the Middle East, Israelis fear it could look vulnerable if it doesn't act decisively now, said Miller.

"If Israel doesn't respond very strongly, very powerfully to this kind of atrocity, then Israel's standing in the region, its deterrence and eventually its integration and acceptance in the region will be challenged because, supposedly, the Arabs will perceive Israel as weak and as fragile," he said.

Clarifications

  • A previous version of this story said Hamas was elected to govern Gaza in 2006. In fact, the 2006 elections were for the Palestinian Legislative Council, which included the Gaza Strip and the West Bank.
    Oct 20, 2023 3:28 PM ET