Peace between Israelis and Palestinians is possible say those dedicated to the cause here's how - Action News
Home WebMail Wednesday, November 13, 2024, 04:50 AM | Calgary | -1.4°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
World

Peace between Israelis and Palestinians is possible say those dedicated to the cause here's how

Oct.7 was a turning point in the decades-long Israeli-Palestinian conflict, with the Hamas-led attack on Israel and the subsequent war in Gaza claiming lives on an unprecedented scale. Activists say education, investment in peacebuilding helped in other conflicts, but visionary political leaders are also key.

Activists say education, investment in peacebuilding helped in other conflicts, but visionary leaders are key

A young boy carries a cat in his arms and a plastic bag as he walks over top of pieces of broken concrete and other debris from a bombed building.
Peace activists say cycles of war haven't resolved Israeli-Palestinian tensions and that peacebuilding efforts need to be supported in order to prevent another generation of children from inheriting the conflict. (Mohammad Ahmad/AFP/Getty Images)

Oct. 7 was a turning point in the decades-long Israeli-Palestinian conflict, with the Hamas-led attack on Israel and the subsequent war in Gaza claiming lives, on each side, on a ferociously unprecedented scale.

The immense pain, trauma, anger and loss will undoubtedly be felt forgenerationsto come, and the possibility of peace between the two sides may seem more distant than ever.But there are scores of people dedicatedto building peace between Israelis and Palestinians on a person-to-person level and they're not ready to give up.

"We inherited this conflict from our parents. Do we want to have our children inherit this conflict or do we want them to inherit peace," asked Palestinian peace activist Mohammed Dajani Daoudi,who is based in Jerusalem. The 77-year-oldfounded a movement called Wasatiathat is aimed at empowering potential leadership in Palestinian society.

For any peace process to succeed, those involved say there need to be shifts in the respective societies in order to reconcile and understand each other's past suffering and to move forward with recognition of the mutual right to a peaceful existence. Any resolution will also require visionary political leaders on both sides willing to negotiate in good faith.

A woman holding a blue and white Israeli flag bends to place a small candle on the ground in front of other candles arranged in the date 7-10 and in the shape of a Star of David.
A woman attends a rally on Nov. 7 in Jerusalem, outside the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, to put pressure on the government to secure the release of hostages held by Palestinian Islamist group Hamas and other militant factions in Gaza, on the one-month anniversary of Hamas's October 7 attack on Israel. (Ronen Zvulun/Reuters)

But the voices of those involved with grassroots peace initiatives often get drowned out by inflammatory political rhetoric and dehumanizing language, saysJohn Lyndon, the executive director of the Alliance for Middle East Peace (ALLMEP), a coalition of over 170 Israeli and Palestinian peacebuilding organizations.

"We should really reflect on why we weren't paying attention to peacebuilding stories before, because they were just as real then and now," he said.

WATCH | Explaining the origins of Hamas and how it came to rule Gaza:

What is Hamas? The story of its origins and rule of Gaza

11 months ago
Duration 5:08
A spotlight was cast on the Islamist militant group Hamas after it unleashed a surprise attack in Israel Oct. 7, killing more than 1,200 people and taking about 240 hostages. How did the group come to be designated a terrorist organization and rule Gaza? CBC's Ashley Fraser explores its origins.

Waging peace to end war

Israel-based Women Wage Peace is one example ofefforts byeveryday citizens organizing to bring a peaceful end to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

The group was formed in the aftermath of Israel's 2014 war with Hamas.

It grew out of the belief that women could make a difference if they were more involved in the prevention and resolution of conflicts. That's something founding member Arielle Ginegar said is meant to be ensured under UN Security Council Resolution 1325, which states that women and girls should have a role in peace and security.

She said the organization has brought together women from across the spectrum in Israel and also aims to build bonds with Palestinian women through a partner organization in the occupied West Bank called Women of the Sun.

The groups held a joint event in Jerusalem on Oct. 4, just days before the violent attack in Israel, to promote what's known as the Mother's Call a statement of unity for a peaceful and secure future for their children and "demanding to end the cycle of bloodshed."

Israel says Hamas and other armed factions from Gaza killed 1,200 Israelis and took about 240 people hostage in the surprise attack on Oct. 7. The Hamas-run Health Ministry in Gaza estimates Israel's military assault on the territory has killed more than 14,000 people so far.

Ginegar admits maintaining optimism during this time is difficult. Some of her fellow peacemakers were killed that day, including her friend Vivian Silver, a Canadian-Israeli humanitarian who was also a founding member of Women Wage Peace.

A woman with white hair and dark sunglasses hold a black placard, with white Hebrew letters, surrounded by other women holding similar signs.
Canadian-Israeli peace activist Vivian Silver takes part in an Aug. 2022 Women Wage Peace demonstration in Tel Aviv meant to call attention to recurring military actions that have not brought about peace and security in the region. Silver, who was born in Winnipeg, died in Hamas's Oct. 7 attack on Israel. (Women Wage Peace)

Ginegar spoke with CBC News from her home in Herzliyanear Tel Aviv, on Nov. 13, shortly before learning of Silver's death. She hadheld out hope for five weeks that the 74-year-old was alive and being held hostage in Gaza.

"The only optimistic thing is that after the [1973 Yom Kippur war] we managed to make peace with Egypt," she said. "Maybe it's not the best peace there is [but] there is a relationship."

LISTEN | Fellow activists vow to find path to peace in Vivian Silver's honour:
Winnipeg-born peace activist Vivian Silver was initially believed to have been taken hostage by Hamas, but her family has now confirmed she was killed in the Oct. 7 attack. Matt Galloway talks to Palestinian and Israeli peace activists who knew her, and who say theyll keep fighting for the path to peace paved by Silver.

Moderation to undermine extremism

Dajani said many wounds need to be healed after this war, but there will come a time when people need to look beyond the horrors of Oct. 7 and the violence inflicted on Gaza and the occupied West Bank, which has seen a surge of Israeli settler attacks and Israeli military raids.

Building peace will require reconciliation, he explained, but also rethinking education.

"We need to have a peace curriculum Our present curriculum in Israel and in Palestine teaches hate of the other. Itdoes not teach living with the other," said Dajani, who once taught a Holocaust studies program at Jerusalem's Al-Quds University and led a group of Palestinian students to visit Auschwitz, the infamous Nazi extermination camp, in 2014.

A man stands in front of a tall barbwire fence running past a small wooden tower. A small sign post is in front of the fence with a skull and crossbones and the words
Mohammed Dajani Daoudi stands in front of buildings at the Auschwitz concentration camp in Poland. Dajani took nearly 30 Palestinian students there in March 2014, when he was a professor at Jerusalem's Al-Quds University. Due to public backlash over the trip, he was later forced to resign from his position at the university. (Submitted by Mohammed Dajani Daoudi)

Public criticism and misinformation about the educational trip, fuelled in part by Holocaust denialin Palestinian society, led to him being forced to resign.

To undermine extremism, Dajani believes Israelis and Palestinians need to try to understand each other's histories and suffering and see each other's humanity.

He saysthat though extremists on either side are in the minority, they're very vocal and violent, and that means ordinarypeople can beafraid of expressing themselves.

Dajani says it was extremists that "derailed" the best attempt at securing Arab-Israeli peace the 1993 Oslo Accord signed by late Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, then-Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

The trio would win the Nobel Peace Prize in 1994, but Rabin was assassinated by a Jewish extremist the next year and Hamas violently opposed the peace process. After a chain of other events, the peace process ultimately fell apart by the early 2000s.

Three men stand in a line holding certificates in folder and small boxes containing round, gold medals.
From left, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres and Israeli Premier Yitzhak Rabin display their Nobel Peace Prizes during a December 1994 ceremony in Oslo, Norway. (Yaakov Saar/GPO/Getty Images)

A Good Friday for Israelis and Palestinians

Though the Oslo Accord didn't succeed, Lyndon says one peace agreement that has persevered and could serve as somewhat of a model for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is the1998 Good Friday Agreement that officially brought an end to nearly three decades of sectarian violence in Northern Ireland, a period known as "The Troubles."

"People in the 1990s, if you ask them, assumed that the Israel-Palestine conflict was easier to resolve," he said in an interview from Paris. "That was the accepted wisdom."

Lyndon, who is from Ireland, said part of what made the Good Friday Agreement successful in maintaining peace for the past quarter century was the international investment in civil society peacebuilding.

For more than a decade before the deal was signed, he explained, foreign governments contributed to the International Fund for Ireland (IFI) to bolster peace efforts by supporting community-led programs working to build trust and facilitate reconciliation, as well as to improve economic advancement and quality of life in disadvantaged areas affected by the violent conflict.

People stand on a street strewn with boards and debris from buildings damaged by a bomb.
Royal Ulster Constabulary Police officers stand at the scene of a car bombing that killed 29 people in the centre of Omagh, west of Belfast, Northern Ireland, on Aug. 15, 1998. The attack was carried out by a paramilitary group that was opposed to the Good Friday Agreement signed four months earlier. (Paul McErlane/The Associated Press)

According to ALLMEP's calculations, donor nations contributed $2.4 billion US equivalent to $44 per person, per year in Northern Ireland to such initiatives between the fund's establishment in 1986 and 2016.

Work supported by the IFI is ongoing, including one projectwhereformer prisoners involved in the conflict engagewith marginalized youth who may be vulnerable to recruitment into violent activities.

"We've never tried anything like [the fund]in Israel-Palestine and the populations have moved further and further apart," Lyndon said.

ALLMEP estimates foreign funding for Israeli and Palestinian civil society peacebuilding works out to just $1.50 US, per person, per year.

LISTEN | The legacy of the Good Friday Agreement and lingering divisions:

Political path to peace

No matter how many ideological bridges are built on a person-to-person basis, the road to peace will ultimately be up to negotiations between Israeli and Palestinian political leaders.

"Civil society doesn't exercise power," said Aaron David Miller, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington, D.C. "[It's] necessary. It's valuable. But it's not sufficient to do what needs to be done."

He points to the example of South Africa, saying apartheid came to an end not because of civil society groups, but due to a combination of external pressure and the emergence of leaders like Nelson Mandela and Frederik Willem de Klerk "who had some measure of vision" to bring about the end of the country's systemic racial oppression.

It's likely both Israelis and Palestinians will go through a period of "political reckoning" after this war, and "presumably" a change in leadership, said Miller, a former U.S. State Department adviser who has participated in U.S.-brokered negotiations.

"The question is whether leaders on both sides will find a way, should they emerge, to reshape these traumatized communities and redirect energy in another direction."

WATCH | Why reaching a formal agreement to stop fighting is so contentious:

Why is a ceasefire in Gaza so contentious? | About That

11 months ago
Duration 11:20
Calls for a ceasefire in Gaza have been growing internationally since the Israel-Hamas war began. Andrew Chang explains why reaching a formal agreement to stop fighting is such a contentious issue among Western allies.