Trump's Supreme Court nominee suggested Watergate decision was maybe 'wrongly decided' - Action News
Home WebMail Thursday, November 14, 2024, 03:35 AM | Calgary | 6.3°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
World

Trump's Supreme Court nominee suggested Watergate decision was maybe 'wrongly decided'

Judge Brett Kavanaugh, U.S. President Donald Trump's nominee to the Supreme Court, suggested several years ago that the unanimous high court ruling in 1974 that forced President Richard Nixon to turn over the Watergate tapes may have been wrongly decided.

Revelation comes from disclosure Kavanaugh provided as part of confirmation process

Brett Kavanaugh was revealed as U.S. President Donald Trump's latest Supreme Court nominee earlier this month. If his nomination is confirmed by the Senate, he will replace longtime top-court jurist and swing-vote Justice Anthony Kennedy. (Manuel Balce Ceneta/The Associated Press)

Judge Brett Kavanaugh, U.S. President Donald Trump's latest nominee to the Supreme Court, suggested several years ago that the unanimous high court ruling in 1974 that forced president Richard Nixon to turn over the Watergate tapes, leading to the end of his presidency, may have been wrongly decided.

Kavanaugh was taking part in a roundtable discussion with other lawyers when he said at three different points that the decision in U.S. v. Nixon, which marked limits on a president's ability to withhold information needed for a criminal prosecution, may have come out the wrong way.

A 1999 magazine article about the roundtable was part of thousands of pages of documents that Kavanaugh has provided to the Senate judiciary committee as part of the confirmation process. The committee released the documents on Saturday.

Kavanaugh's belief in robust executive authority already is front and centre in his nominationto replace retiring Justice Anthony Kennedy. The issue could assume even greater importance if special counsel Robert Mueller seeks to force Trump to testify in the ongoing investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election.

'Maybe Nixon was wrongly decided'

"But maybe Nixon was wrongly decided heresy though it is to say so. Nixon took away the power of the president to control information in the executive branch by holding that the courts had power and jurisdiction to order the president to disclose information in response to a subpoena sought by a subordinate executive branch official. That was a huge step with implications to this day that most people do not appreciate sufficiently ... Maybe the tension of the time led to an erroneous decision," Kavanaugh said in a transcript of the discussion that was published in a 1999 issue of the Washington Lawyer.

Philip Lacovara, who argued the Watergate tapes case against Nixon and moderated the discussion, said Kavanaugh has long believed in a strong presidency. "That was Brett staking out what has been his basic jurisprudential approach since law school," Lacovara said in a telephone interview Saturday.

Still, Lacovara said, "it was surprising even as of 1999 that the unanimous decision in the Nixon tapes case might have been wrongly decided.

The article was among a pile of material released in response to the committee's questionnaire. Kavanaugh was asked to provide information about his career as an attorney and jurist, his service in the executive branch, education, society memberships and more.

A longtime figure in the Washington establishment, Kavanaugh acknowledged in the questionnaire that he had joined clubs that he said once had discriminatory membership policies.

"Years before I became a member of the Congressional Country Club and the Chevy Chase Club, it is my understanding that those clubs, like most similar clubs around the country, may have excluded members on discriminatory bases that should not have been acceptable to people then and would not be acceptable now," he wrote.

Kavanaugh lists 10 most important rulings

Asked to list the 10 most significant cases for which he sat as a judge, Kavanaugh cited nine in which "the position expressed in my opinion (either for the court or in a separate writing) was later adopted by the Supreme Court."

The 10th regarded a man fired by mortgage giant Fannie Mae after he filed a discrimination complaint that alleged a company executive had created a hostile work environment by calling the worker "the n-word." Kavanaugh said he included it "because of what it says about anti-discrimination law and American history."

Kavanaugh's nomination was officially unveiled by Trump during a press conference at the White House on July 9. His questionnaire for the Senate Judicial Committee is the latest step in his confirmation process. (Evan Vucci/The Associated Press)

Kavanaugh said an appeals court panel on which he sat reversed a lower court's ruling in favour of Fannie Mae. He said he joined the majority opinion and wrote a separate concurrence "to explain that calling someone the n-word, even once, creates a hostile work environment."

In the questionnaire, Kavanaugh cited his opinion in that case: "No other word in the English language so powerfully or instantly calls to mind our country's long and brutal struggle to overcome racism and discrimination against African-Americans."' But it was one of the relatively few discrimination cases in which Kavanaugh sided with a complaining employee.

Details of nomination also divulged

Offering a timeline leading to his nomination, he said White House counsel Don McGahn called him the day Justice Anthony Kennedy announced his retirement, June 27, and they met the next day. Trump interviewed him July 2, with McGahn present, and Vice President Mike Pence interviewed him July 4. Kavanaugh spoke by phone with the president on July 8 and that evening met at the White House with Trump and his wife, Melania, where he said he was offered and accepted the nomination.

Asked whether anyone sought assurances from him about the stand he might take on a specific case or issue, he answered "No." He also said he had not offered any indication how he might rule as a justice.

Kavanaugh has written some 300 rulings as an appeals court judge and has a record in the George W. Bush White House as well as in Kenneth Starr's probe of President Bill Clinton that led to Clinton's impeachment trial in the1990s.

Republican Sen. Chuck Grassley, the committee chairman, said the questionnaire was "the broadest and most comprehensive" ever sent by the committee and he welcomed "Judge Kavanaugh's diligent and timely response."

The nominee told lawmakers he registered for the Selective Service in his younger days but did not serve in the armed forces.