The Highest-Rated Women's Sweaters For That Weird In-Between Weather

Score: 4.6 out of 5 stars; 527 ratings at Target

Soft, perfectly slouchy and a breeze to throw on, this open-front cardigan is one of Target's most-rated sweater options and reviewers call it "comfortable" and "the perfect length." It's slightly oversized, has a pointelle pattern and two functional pockets and comes in two colors. Best of all, it's 45% off right now, making it a good under-$20 find for fall! Grab this in sizes 2X-4X.

Score: 4.4 out of 5 stars; 24,137 ratings at Amazon

This classic-fitting V-neck sweater promises to be lightweight, comfortable and never bulky so it's perfect for a nearly fall climate. It's made from a cotton-modal blend, comes in 31 colors and sizes XS-6X.

Promising review: "This turned out to be one of my favorite light weight sweaters. Its prefect for cool fall evenings or worn layered with something else in the winter. I wear mine often times with a down vest during winter months. I have this same sweater in black also. I love that its a v-neck sweater. Its not overly fitted which is my personal preference, not bulky either. Its comfy and flattering and comes in a variety of colors so chances are Ill get another one.or two. Washes very well, no noticeable shrinkage, and holds it shape." Debra Kirby

Score: 4.4 out of 5 stars; 14,222 ratings at Amazon

Shopping managing editor Emily Ruane is a big fan of this delicate-yet-functional Amazon cardigan that she said is a dead ringer for one popular J.Crew cardigan that's nearly double the cost (and completely sold out). Made from a lightweight cotton blend and available in over 25 colors, this classic button-up is sure to be your next favorite basic. Find it in sizes XS-6X.

Score: 4.4 out of 5 stars; 23,602 ratings at Amazon

Another Amazon essential basic is this open-front cardigan that's perfect for layering and a mid-thigh length. It's made from a cotton-modal blend, comes in 20 colors and sizes XS-6X. Reviewers note that this is especially ideal for traveling.

Promising review: "I wanted something I can cram into my personal item for the plane. You know how after 30 minutes being herded like cattle, it's 95 F in the jetway? You sit on the tarmac for the obligatory 45 minutes and the flight attendants are about to pass out in their polyester uniforms, so as soon as your flight is clear to take off the air handler comes on and suddenly you could store popsicles in economy class? This is the garment you want on hand... It's well sewn and drapes gracefully should you wish to conceal something like a passport wallet on a string or a well-trained chihuahua. It comes down a bit past your hips and gives the vague impression of a blazer. I think the weave is dense enough to pin a brooch or an ID tag onto without destroying it... I'm off to buy another one while they're on sale. If you're a traveler who gets cold, or just want something a bit more stylish than a sweatshirt to keep you warm, get one of these." Aunt Mary [Note: This review has been edited for length. Read the full review here .]

Score: 105 5-stars out of 133 ratings at Old Navy

For a touch of non-bulky warmth that doubles as a stylish outfit addition, look no further than this V-neck layering vest that has a semi-close fit, ribbed trim detailing and a cotton blend construction. It's available in four colors and sizes XS-4X, with options for tall, petite and regular.

Score: 4.5 out of 5 stars; 8,313 reviews at Amazon

Available in 18 colors and sizes S-XXL, this waffle-knit pullover has a curved hemline and an oversized fit that's perfect for wearing on its own or layering over an outfit if the day suddenly turns brisk.

Be sure to apply the 30% off coupon on the product page before checkout.

Promising review: "Bought 3 of these (bought 1 and liked it and kept buying ) 3 + years ago and no holes, no fading, no piling. I wear them a lot and they are the most quality pieces of clothing in current wardrobe. Thick fabric, not as long as they appear in photos." CoffeeFreakz

Score: 147 5-stars out of 169 ratings at Gap

This perfectly oversized polo-style sweater is a cozy must-have that pairs seamlessly with jeans, leggings and anything in between. It has a split hem detailing and comes in four stripe color options. It's also on sale right now with an extra 60% off the existing markdown at checkout so now's the perfect time to scoop it up. Find it in sizes XXS-XXL, with options for regular, tall and petite.

Score: 4.9 out of 5 stars; 13,669 reviews at Quince

Quince is known for supplying the internet with luxurious cashmere garments at accessible price points, and this crewneck is a perfect example. One of the best and most highly rated sweaters from the brand, this timeless pullover is made from a silky soft and lightweight Mongolian cashmere, yet costs just $50. It's available in 16 colors, sizes XS-XL and also comes in an equally high-rated oversized version for $119.

Score: 5 out of 5 stars; 16 ratings at Nordstrom

Reviewers tout this versatile sweater as being "not too light and not too heavy" and impeccably "well made." It features a longline design and tie waist that can be worn either in the front or back. You can get it in three neutral colors and sizes 0-12.

Score: 4.5 out of 5-stars at Everlane

This everyday half-zip pullover is made from a premium and chunky knit cotton for a feeling that's breathable and comfortable. The fit is slightly oversized so it can be easy to throw on over T-shirts and it comes in four colors as well as sizes XXS-XXL.

Score: 4.9 out of 5 stars at J.Crew

Rather than accessorizing with a heavy coat or unseasonably warm jacket, this classic Audrey Hepburn-esque cardigan is part sweater, part jacket and has a fit ideal for layering. It's made from 100% cotton and is adorned with heritage-inspired gold crest buttons. You can find it in two solid colors, two striped options and sizes XXS-3X. Per the reviews, it can run big so eye the size chart and size down as you see fit.

Score: 4.6 out of 5 stars; 542 reviews at Free People

This chunky knit tunic sweater is intentionally oversized with roomy dolman sleeves and a relaxed hip-skimming hemline. Find it in sizes XS-XL and up to 11 colors including a cool-toned lilac, a rich pumpkin and black. Per the reviewers, this oversized design fits extra big so definitely eye the size chart and the review photos to get a sense of what might be the best fit for you. The upside? Sizing was nearly the only complaint we found about this stunning sweater.

Promising review: "Hands down my new go to sweater. It is oversized and comfortable, it has a good shape and washes well." Sara Wood

Score: 4.8 out of 5 stars; 2,527 reviews at Quince

Referred to by Quince as the "boyfriend cardigan," this relaxed-fit button-up is knit from the brand's signature and supremely soft Mongolian cashmere and features a fisherman rib detailing. You can find it in 11 colors and sizes XS-XL.

Promising review: "Ive had this cardigan for a few months now and it is one of the coziest cardigans I own. It is def an investment and I was second guessing keeping it but Ive worn my moneys worth at this point. I wear it both at work and lounging around the house pretty regularly. This cardigan is oversized already so I could have sized down but ended up just keeping my normal size. Its a nice capsule piece and it does pill over time so have a fabric shaver handy." Kat