Transgender student says some Canadians need 3rd option for gender on census

Quinn Nelson wantsto be counted in the 2016 long-form census, but when it comesto the question of gender identity there's a problem:Nelson is transgender and identifies as neither male nor female.

"As a non-binary person, often when I fill out forms there's only two options given to me and that's not enough for me," Nelson said in an interview on CBC'sPower & Politics.

• Saskatchewan teen wants to change gender on ID without surgery
• Manitoba appoints first transgender judge Kael McKenzie
• Facebook makes changes to 'real names' policy after complaints

In November, Nelson wrote an email toNavdeep Bains, the minister responsible for Statistics Canada and the census.Nelson didn't want to violate the law by not filling out the questionnaire.

The University of Calgary sociology student also wanted to make sure Statistics Canada was going to provide anaccurate reflection of the country.

Transgender student says some Canadians need 3rd option for gender on census

9 years ago

Duration 7:03

Quinn Nelson wants to see an 'other' option along with 'male' or 'female' on the long-form census.

The census assumes that 100 per cent of the respondents can answer that they areeither male or female, "and that's not accurate," Nelson said.

"The census is used by a lot of policy makers, sociologists and government officials to make decisions. They really need to know what their population is. That's the point of the census."

Nelson said if the census includes a category for non-binary transgender people it wouldbe an important acknowledgment. It could help with the allocation of resources in the health-care systemand teachpeople to interact respectfullywith transgender people, Nelson said.

'Answer neither'

Bains hasn't responded to Nelson, butStatistics Canada did. Deputy chief statistician Connie Graziadei saidthe 2016 census questionnaire had already been approved and published, but there is an option forNelson.

"I was told to answer neither, to leave the question blank; also to answer in the comments why I found the question inadequate."

Nelson posted the exchange on Facebookin early January. The Statistics Canada response also says it will hold public consultations on the 2021 questionnaire and that willbe an opportunity to "evaluate if there are new ways to collect data on sex for respondents who do not identify themselves with the current response options."

Male, female, other

Nelson was happy with Statistics Canada's response, butsaid the 2021 questionnaire should allow three responses to the gender question:male, female or other.

"The reality is the vast majority of people will fit into either the male or female. And other, while it isn't specific, is still good information."

Nelson said the option would helpStatistics Canadadetermine the most effective and accurate way to track the transgender population in Canada in the future.