Every few months, Oreo unleashes a new flavor on unsuspecting grocery shoppers. They generally range from delicious (hello Red Velvet and Cinnamon Bun ), to the highly questionable (lookin at you, Swedish Fish and Watermelon).

Now that Peeps-flavored Oreos are hitting the shelves, it seems were back to a questionable choice. Thats right folks, Americas least favorite Easter treat combined forces with Americas favorite cookie to make this: